RZAYEV v. AZERBAIJAN

Publicat la 8 iulie 2024 PRIMEA SECȚIUNE Cerere nr. 1323/23 Hasangulu RZAYEV împotriva Azerbaidjanului și alte 10 cereri (a se vedea lista anexată) comunicată la 17 iunie 2024 OBIECTUL CAUZEI Prezenta cerere se referă la legalitatea interdicțiilor de călătorie impuse de autoritățile interne reclamanților în cadrul diferitelor proceduri penale în care nu au fost condamnate, acuzate sau suspectate și la disponibilitatea unui remediu intern eficace la dispoziția acestora în acest sens. A fost pusă vreo restricție asupra libertății reclamanților de a părăsi teritoriul statului contestat, astfel cum este garantat de art. 2 § 2 din Protocolul nr. 4 la Convenție? Dacă este cazul, această restricție a fost în conformitate cu legea și necesară în conformitate cu art. 2 § 3 din Protocolul nr. 4 la Convenție?

Toate cererile cu excepția nr. 8938/24: Reclamanții au la dispoziția lor un remediu intern eficace pentru plângerile lor în temeiul articolului 2 din Protocolul nr. 4 la Convenție, astfel cum este prevăzut la art. 13 din Convenție?

Apendice No. de cerere nr. Numărul de caz Lodged on Candidat An of Residence Place of Residence Reprezentat de 1323/23 Rzayev c. Azerbaidjan 21/12/2022 Hasangul Sabir oglu RZAYEV 1989, Sumgayit Javad JAVADOV 1328/23 Mustafayev v. Azerbaidjan 21/12/2022 Samir Nariman oglu MUSEAFAYEV 1988, Baku Javad JAVADOV 3273/23 Gahramanli v. Azerbaidjan 23/12/2022 Khayal Ramiz oglu GAHRAMANLI 1999, Sumgayit Zibeyda SADIGOVA 4441/23 Ibrahim v. Azerbaidjan 23/12/2022 Nijad Ibad oglu IBRAHIM 1975, Baku Zibeyda SADIGOVA 15356/23 Suleymanov v. Azerbaidjan 15/03/2023 Abgul Neymat oglu SULEYMANOV 1976, Baku Javad JAVADOV 18848/23 Jafarov v. Azerbaidjan 05/04/2023 Tamkin Kamal oglu JAFAROV 1978, Baku Javad JAVADOV 31521/23 Abdullayeva v. Azerbaidjan 25/07/2023 Tarana Isyaman gizi ABDULLAYEVA 1964, Baku Javad JAVADOV 31530/23 Shiriyev v. Azerbaidjan 25/07/2023 Rais Tofig oglu SHIRIYEV 1968, Baku Javad JAVADOV 39092/23 Abdullayeva v. Azerbaidjan 27/10/2023 Zeynab Bayramali gizi ABDULLAYEVA 1950, Baku Javad JAVADOV 10. 40261/23 Sarijanova v. Azerbaidjan 06/11/2023 Elnara Akif gizi SARIJANOVA 1978, Absheron Javad JAVADOV 11. 8938/24 Sarkayev v. Azerbaidjan 07/03/2024 Abdulla Ali oglu SARCAYEV 1989, Khirdalan Elchin SADIGOV

Published on 8 July 2024

FIRST SECTION

Application no. 1323/23 Hasangulu RZAYEV against Azerbaijan and 10 other applications (see list appended) communicated on 17 June 2024

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

The present applications concern the lawfulness of travel bans imposed by the domestic authorities on the applicants within the framework of various criminal proceedings in which they were not convicted, accused or suspected persons and the availability of an effective domestic remedy at their disposal in that connection.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

All applications: 1. Was any restriction placed on the applicants’ freedom to leave the territory of the respondent State, as guaranteed by Article 2 § 2 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention? If so, was that restriction in accordance with the law and necessary in terms of Article 2 § 3 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention? All applications except no. 8938/24: 2. Did the applicants have at their disposal an effective domestic remedy for their complaints under Article 2 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention, as required by Article 13 of the Convention?

APPENDIX No. Application no. Case name Lodged on Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Represented by 1. 1323/23 Rzayev v. Azerbaijan 21/12/2022 Hasangulu Sabir oglu RZAYEV 1989, Sumgayit Javad JAVADOV 2. 1328/23 Mustafayev v. Azerbaijan 21/12/2022 Samir Nariman oglu MUSTAFAYEV 1988, Baku Javad JAVADOV 3. 3273/23 Gahramanli v. Azerbaijan 23/12/2022 Khayal Ramiz oglu GAHRAMANLI 1999, Sumgayit Zibeyda SADIGOVA 4. 4441/23 Ibrahim v. Azerbaijan 23/12/2022 Nijad Ibad oglu IBRAHIM 1975, Baku Zibeyda SADIGOVA 5. 15356/23 Suleymanov v. Azerbaijan 15/03/2023 Abgul Neymat oglu SULEYMANOV 1976, Baku Javad JAVADOV 6. 18848/23 Jafarov v. Azerbaijan 05/04/2023 Tamkin Kamal oglu JAFAROV 1978, Baku Javad JAVADOV 7. 31521/23 Abdullayeva v. Azerbaijan 25/07/2023 Tarana Isyaman gizi ABDULLAYEVA 1964, Baku Javad JAVADOV 8. 31530/23 Shiriyev v. Azerbaijan 25/07/2023 Rais Tofig oglu SHIRIYEV 1968, Baku Javad JAVADOV 9. 39092/23 Abdullayeva v. Azerbaijan 27/10/2023 Zeynab Bayramali gizi ABDULLAYEVA 1950, Baku Javad JAVADOV 10. 40261/23 Sarijanova v. Azerbaijan 06/11/2023 Elnara Akif gizi SARIJANOVA 1978, Absheron Javad JAVADOV 11. 8938/24 Sarkayev v. Azerbaijan 07/03/2024 Abdulla Ali oglu SARKAYEV 1989, Khirdalan Elchin SADIGOV