Shulika împotriva Rusiei și alte 31 cereri

SECȚIUNEA A PATRU

Publicată pe 23 februarie 2026 CEREREA NR. 19246/24 Andriy Anatoliyovych SHULIKA împotriva Rusiei și alte 31 de cereri (vezi tabelul anexat)

INFORMAȚII PROCEDURALE

După o examinare preliminară a admisibilității cererilor pe 5 februarie 2026, Curtea a decis, în conformitate cu Regula 54 § 2 (b) din Regulamentul Curții, că notificarea cererilor ar trebui dată Guvernului Rusiei. Se observă că chestiunea jurisdicției asupra zonei în care s-au petrecut evenimentele la care se referă cererea prezintă aspecte delicate legate de aplicabilitatea Convenției în circumstanțele specifice ale conflictului din Ucraina. Reclamantul Andriy Anatoliyovych Shulika și ceilalți reclamanti susțin violări ale mai multor drepturi protejate de Convenție, inclusiv dreptul la viață, dreptul la libertate și la integritate fizică, în legătură cu acțiunile unor forțe militare în Ucraina.

Prin notificarea cererilor, Curtea intenționează să colecteze observațiile Guvernului Rusiei cu privire la admisibilitate și fond, și să determine în ce măsură statele au obligații sub Convenție în circumstanțe precum cel al unui conflict armat. Curtea constată că aceste cereri ridică chestiuni jurisprudențiale importante și complexe care necesită o examinare amănunțită de o Cameră a Curții. Semnat și comunicat pe 23 februarie 2026. (Urmează informații detaliate și lista aplicațiilor colegate)

Published on 23 February 2026

FOURTH SECTION

Application no. 19246/24 Andriy Anatoliyovych SHULIKA against Russia and 31 other applications (see table appended)

PROCEDURAL INFORMATION

Following a preliminary examination of the admissibility of the applications on 5 February 2026, the Court decided, under Rule 54 § 2 (b) of the Rules of Court, that notice of the applications should be given to the Government of Russia. It is to be noted that the issue of jurisdiction over the area where the incidents giving rise to the complaints allegedly took place has been examined and decided by the Grand Chamber of the Court in the case of Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia ([GC], nos. 8019/16 and 3 others, §§ 327-66, 9 July 2025). The Grand Chamber’s finding will then be applied in these individual cases. In some applications, other complaints were raised. Their examination has been adjourned, or they have been struck out of the Court’s list of cases or declared inadmissible by the Court, sitting in a single-judge formation, assisted by a rapporteur as provided for in Article 24 § 2 of the Convention.

In the enclosed table, whenever an applicant is referred to using initials, this indicates that the Court has authorised anonymity for that person, whose identity will not be disclosed to the public (Rule 47 § 4). For further information on the procedure following communication of an application brought against Russia, subject of well-established case law of the Court, please refer to the Court’s Internet Site .

SUBJECT MATTER

The applications concern complaints raised under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 13 of the Convention relating to damage, destruction and/or continuous lack of access to property arising from the conflict between Russia and Ukraine and the lack of any effective remedy in domestic law which are the subject of well-established case law of the Court (see Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia ([GC], nos. 8019/16 and 3 others, §§ 768-72 and 1622, 9 July 2025).

APPENDIX – STATEMENT OF FACTS

List of applications raising complaints under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 13 of the Convention (damage, destruction and/or continuous lack of access to property arising from the conflict between Russia and Ukraine and the lack of any effective remedy in domestic law) No. Application no. Date of introduction Applicant’s name Year of birth Property allegedly damaged (description and location) Dates / Period when damage occurred and when the applicant learned about it Evidence provided (photos, property certificate, etc.) Level of damage Other complaints under well-established case-law 19246/24 26/06/2022 Andriy Anatoliyovych SHULIKA 1978 Apartment no. 3 (65.6 sq. m) at 139 Nikopolskyi (previously Illicha) Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling on 05/04/2022.

On 21/04/2022 the applicant lodged an online application about property damage via the DIIA website. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title document (the applicant owns ½ share in the apartment – extract from the real estate register dated 06/03/2014); photos of the property after the damage (damaged windows, balcony, doors, furniture; belongings turned upside down); screenshot of the online application about property damage submitted via the DIIA website on 21/04/2022; IDP certificate issued in Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region on 24/03/2022. loss of access to property, damage Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport and statements, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia region (IDP certificate issued on 24/03/2022).

19747/24 09/08/2022 Vira Mykolayivna PONKO 1963 Private house (35.6 sq. m) at 1 Bohdana St (previously at 2 Pionera Balabukhy St), Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by phosphoric bombs between 09/04/2022 and 10/04/2022. On 20/05/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the regional prosecutor’s office.

The applicant’s passport; residence registration certificate for the private house dated 19/07/2022; title document (the applicant owns 43/100 in the private house - purchase agreement dated 02/12/2006); photos of the house before the destruction, depicting its interior and elements of the applicant’s family life; photos of the house after the destruction (destroyed to the ground; everything covered in rubble); the applicant’s complaints to the regional prosecutor’s office and General Prosecutor’s Office of Ukraine dated 20/05/2022 and 27/07/2022 respectively, along with their responses dated 02/08/2022; victim’s memo dated 20/05/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 29/07/2022; witness statements, containing a detailed list of the destroyed belongings dated 01/08/2022; IDP certificate issued in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region dated 06/04/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the private house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence registration certificate dated 19/07/2022, the applicant’s and witness’ statements, and photos of the house before the destruction, depicting elements of the applicant’s family life, which she was forced to abandon on 21/03/2022 and relocate to Dnipro (IDP certificate issued in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region dated 06/04/2022). 22207/24 04/07/2022 Rayisa Mykolayivna KUZMINA 1993 (1) Apartment no. 61 (63.8 sq. m) at 11 Lomizova (Tsymlianska) St, Mariupol, Donetsk region; (2) Apartment no. 6 (44.12 sq.

m) at 34 Azovstalska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling between 08/03/2022 and 20/04/2022. On 24/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police. The applicant’s passport; marriage certificate confirming the change of the applicant’s last name dated 19/09/2020; title documents (for the apartment 1 - deed of gift and extract from the real estate register dated 26/06/2020; for the apartment 2 – purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 12/03/2020); photos of the apartments taken prior to their destruction showing the interior and the applicant’s daily life; photos of the destroyed property (completely burnt down and reduced to rubble residential buildings); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 25/06/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 24/06/2022; receipts for the purchase of household appliances; IDP certificate dated 30/05/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to flee her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, after 20/04/2022, and relocate to Lutsk, Volyn region (IDP certificate dated 30/05/2022). 22395/24 02/07/2022 Oleksiy Ivanovych IVASHCHENKO 1973 Private house (41.2 sq. m) at 19 Blahovisna (previously Blahoieva) St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 08/04/2022. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title document (deed of gift dated 07/09/2004); photos of the destroyed house (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble; no walls left; traces of fire; courtyard covered in rubble); envelope with the address in Staryi Lysets, Ivano-Frankivsk region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that he had been forced to flee his home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Staryi Lysets, Ivano-Frankivsk region (envelope with the address in Staryi Lysets, Ivano-Frankivsk region). 22792/24 03/08/2022 Rita Yevgenivna MAKAROVA 1985 Apartment no. 26 (51.5 sq. m) at 60 Hromovoi St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 09/04/2022. On 11/05/2022 the applicant lodged an online application about the destroyed property via the DIIA website.

The applicant’s passport with a residence registration stamp for another address in Mariupol; title documents (property registration certificate dated 21/05/1992; ownership certificate dated 15/08/1994; deed of gift and technical passport dated 21/05/1998); photos of the destroyed property (completely destroyed and reduce to rubble); screenshot of the online application about the destroyed property submitted via the DIIA website on 11/05/2022; envelope with the address in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to flee her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region (envelope with the address in Dnipro, Dnipropetrovsk region).

22999/24 27/07/2022 Nadiya Leonidivna SMOLYANINOVA 1955 Private house (93.3 sq. m) at 38 Kronshtadska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling at the beginning of April 2022. On 11/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (inheritance certificate and extract from the inheritance register, both dated 05/10/2018; technical passport dated 25/07/2018); photos of the house after the damage (damaged roof; external walls damaged by shrapnel; broken windows; belongings turned upside-down); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 13/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 11/07/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date; envelope with the address in Cherkasy region.

damage, loss of access to property Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the private house in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Cherkasy region (envelope with the address in Cherkasy region). 23460/24 09/07/2022 Olena Illivna BUGA 1983 Apartment no. 20 (108.7 sq. m) at 80 Nakhymova Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly damaged by artillery shelling in April 2022. The applicant’s passport; title documents (purchase agreement and extract from the state register of deeds dated 11/06/2011; extract from the real estate register dated 21/06/2011; technical passport dated 07/06/2011); photos of the damaged apartment (damaged windows; damaged ceiling and floor; damaged belongings); envelope with the address in Kyiv.

loss of access to property, damage Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to flee her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Kyiv (envelope with an address in Kyiv). 24055/24 12/08/2022 Olga Yuriyivna AGUDOVA 1970 Apartment no. 38 (72.47 sq. m), at 51 Kuindzhi (previously Artema) St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling in March-April 2022. The applicant learned about the destruction on 18/04/2022.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; residence registration certificate dated 26/11/2021; divorce certificate confirming the change of the applicant’s last name dated 20/09/1999; title documents (the applicant owns ¼ share in the apartment - purchase agreement dated 10/12/1997; property registration certificate dated 11/12/1997); photos of the apartment taken prior to its destruction showing the interior of the apartment and elements of the daily life; photos of the destroyed residential building with signs of fire; envelope with the address in Avanhard village, Odesa region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Avanhard village, Odesa region (envelope with an address in Avanhard village, Odesa region). 24328/24 30/07/2022 Olena Oleksandrivna AKYMENKO 1961 Apartment no. 145 (35.7 sq. m) at 120 Polietaieva St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 02/04/2022. On 27/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (extract from the real estate register dated 14/11/2005; technical passport dated 14/11/2005); photos of the apartment after the destruction (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble residential building; few walls left; no windows left; destroyed roof; yard covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 06/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint; envelope with the address in Kyiv. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon on 16/03/2022 and relocate to Kyiv, Kyiv region (envelope with the address in Kyiv).

24557/24 04/08/2022 Vira Volodymyrivna REKOTA 1964 Apartment no. 71 (45.3 sq. m) at 82 Kyivska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 15/04/2022. On 14/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the General Prosecutor’s Office of Ukraine.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (inheritance certificate and extract from the real estate register, both dated 27/05/2014); photos of the apartment before the destruction, depicting the elements of interior and personal belongings; photos of the property after the destruction (traces of fire on the facade; broken windows and damaged balconies; destroyed walls, everything covered in rubble); complaint to the police dated 14/07/2022; extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 24/02/2022; screenshot of the online application (submission no. 938460) to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 19/07/2022; IDP certificate dated 22/07/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Dnipropetrovsk region (IDP certificate dated 22/07/2022). 27539/24 08/08/2022 Nina Volodymyrivna POPOVA 1986 (1) Private house and outbuildings (summer kitchen, barn) (200.2 sq. m) at 34 Haharina St, Mariupol, Donetsk region; (2) Land plot (0.1000 ha) at 34 Haharina St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling in April 2022. On 27/04/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant lost access to her land plot due to fleeing from Mariupol. The applicant’s passport; title documents (deeds of gift and extracts from the real estate register dated 20/01/2022); photos and videos of the house taken prior to its destruction showing the interior of the house, elements of daily life, the applicants’ family members; photos and videos of the destroyed property (destroyed roof and walls; unfit for habitation); complaint to the Ukrainian police dated 27/04/2022; victim’s memo issued by the Ukrainian police on 27/04/2022; interrogation report dated 27/04/2022; IDP certificate dated 01/07/2022. loss of access to property, complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to flee her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Kremenchuk, Poltava region (IDP certificate dated 01/07/2022).

28254/24 05/09/2022 Iryna Pavlivna DYACHENKO 1957 Apartment no. 83 (45.9 sq. m) at 3 Volhodonska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling in April 2022. On 26/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title document (the applicant owns 1/2 share in the apartment - extract from the real estate register dated 15/07/2014); photos of the destroyed apartment (completely burnt down and destroyed residential building; explosion holes in the external facade; few walls left; debris in the yard); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 27/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 26/06/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 05/09/2022; IDP certificate dated 03/05/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Shepiivka village, Khmilnik district, Vinnytsia region (IDP certificate dated 03/05/2022). 30598/24 27/07/2022 Nina Ivanivna LUKANINA 1955 Apartment no. 7 (37.1 sq. m) at 47 Heorhiivska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by an airstrike on 14/04/2022. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (purchase agreement dated 16/01/2010; extract from the real estate register dated 03/02/2010; extract from the state register of agreements dated 16/01/2010); photos of the destroyed apartment (completely destroyed; few walls left standing; traces of fire); envelope with the address in Zhytomyr, Zhytomyr region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Zhytomyr, Zhytomyr region (envelope with the address in Zhytomyr, Zhytomyr region). 31105/24 01/09/2022 Olena Vasylivna PROSKURYAKOVA 1972 Apartment no. 12 (56.31 sq. m) at 34 Azovstalska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 04/04/2022. On 07/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (purchase agreement, registration certificate, technical passport, all dated 29/12/1999); photos of the destroyed apartment (completely destroyed; destroyed balconies; traces of burning and soot on the facade; everything covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 09/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 07/07/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date; IDP certificate dated 05/04/2022. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Khmelnytskyi, Khmelnytskyi region (IDP certificate dated 05/04/2022).

31577/24 16/09/2022 Iryna Borysivna GLYEBOVA 1955 (1) Apartment no. 181 (62.3 sq. m) at 16 Novorosiiska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region; (2) Apartment no. 15 (54 sq. m) at 25 Lunina Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling between 01/04/2022 and 30/04/2022. On 08/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport; title documents (for the apartment 1 - deed of gift and extract from the real estate register dated 13/11/2020; technical passport dated 02/08/2011; for the apartment 2 – purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 19/06/2020); photos of the destroyed property (completely burnt down multi-storey building in which the apartment was located); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 07/09/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 08/08/2022; extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 13/09/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 09/09/2022; handwritten application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 15/09/2022; witness statements concerning the destroyed household appliances dated 15/09/2022; IDP certificate dated 14/06/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to flee her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region and relocate to Kyiv (IDP certificate dated 14/06/2022). 31594/24 16/09/2022 Olena Vladyslavivna KOROLYOVA 1970 Apartment no. 7 (27.3 sq. m) at 134 Nakhymova Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 13/04/2022. On 29/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport; title documents (purchase agreement dated 22/04/2021; extract from the real estate register dated 22/04/2021; statement of the applicant’s husband on personal private ownership of his wife for the apartment in question dated 22/04/2021); photos of the apartment before its destruction; photos of the destroyed apartment (destroyed walls; everything covered in rubble); complaint to the Ukrainian police dated 29/06/2022; extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 30/06/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 29/06/2022; the applicant’s handwritten statement dated 16/09/2022. complete destruction 31612/24 14/09/2022 Valentyna Volodymyrivna BAKHAL 1961 Apartment no. 10 (81.3 sq.

m) at 11 Pashkovskoho St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 05/04/2022. On 04/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police. The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (ownership certificate dated 26/11/2012; extract from the real estate register dated 21/12/2012); photos of the destroyed apartment (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble; explosion holes in the walls; few walls left; no windows left; destroyed furniture; rooms and yard covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 18/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 04/08/2022; victim’s memo dated 18/08/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 14/09/2022; IDP certificate dated 12/08/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Mohyliv-Podilskyi, Vinnytsia region (IDP certificate dated 12/08/2022). 32193/24 06/09/2022 Lyubov Mykolayivna NURGAYANOVA 1951 Apartment no. 26 (42.28 sq. m) at 7 Zelinskoho St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed between 01/04/2022 and 06/04/2022. On 01/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the apartment – deed of gift dated 11/01/2008; extract from the real estate register dated 04/02/2008; inheritance certificate dated 06/09/2007; extract from the real estate register dated 11/09/2007); photos of the residential building after the destruction (destroyed windows and balconies; traces of fire on the facade; walls damaged by shrapnel; fragments of concrete blocks in the apartment; damaged furniture); police certificate and extract from the register of pre-trial investigations, both dated 01/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on the same date; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 11/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 14/04/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Vinnytsia region (IDP certificate dated 14/04/2022). 32529/24 05/08/2022 Yevgen Volodymyrovych YURCHENKO 1982 Private house and outbuildings (202.9 sq. m) at 8 Klynova St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed between 07/04/2022 and 15/04/2022. On 05/07/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the house - technical passport dated 12/04/2018; extract from the real estate register dated 17/05/2018); photos of the private house prior to its destruction, showing the applicant’s family life, interior and personal belongings; photographs of the destroyed house (no walls left; everything covered in rubble; private house reduced to rubble; completely burned down vehicle); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 21/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 05/07/2022; police report dated 22/07/2022; witness statements confirming the alleged destruction of the house between 07/04/2022 and 15/04/2022, dated 01/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 08/07/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the private house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport, photos of the house prior to its destruction and his statements, which he was forced to abandon in April 2022 and relocate to Kyiv, Kyiv region (IDP certificate dated 08/07/2022). 33479/24 30/06/2022 Olena Volodymyrivna MORYEVA 1975 Private house (68.6 sq. m) at 145 Kosmodemianskoi St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed as a result of artillery shelling on 15/04/2022.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for another address in Mariupol; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the private hose – deed of gift and extract from the real estate register dated 04/11/2003); photos of the private house after the destruction (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble; few walls left; no windows left; destroyed roof; yard covered in rubble); envelope with the address in Ivano-Frankivsk region. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that she had been forced to abandon her home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, on 20/04/2022, and relocate to Yablunytsia, Ivano-Frankivsk region (envelope with the address in Ivano-Frankivsk region).

33510/24 19/08/2022 Antonina Volodymyrivna GARAN 1979 Kostyantyn Yevgenovych GARAN 2003 Apartment no. 61 (45 sq. m) at 10 Novorosiiska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by a missile strike in April 2022. On 16/08/2022 Ms Garan lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police. The passport of Ms Garan with a residence stamp for the apartment; ID card of Mr Garan; extract from the demographic register indicating Mr Garan’s place of residence in Mariupol, dated 23/12/2021; title documents (joint ownership, each applicant owns a 1/2 share in the apartment - inheritance certificates dated 24/09/2013; extract from the real estate register dated 24/09/2013); photos and video of the destroyed apartment (completely burnt down; destroyed entrance door; burnt ceilings and walls inside; burnt stairs; everything covered in rubble); police report dated 17/08/2022; envelope with the address in Kyiv.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicants complained that they had been forced to flee their home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Kyiv (envelope with the address in Kyiv). 33646/24 03/08/2022 Yevgen Dmytrovych MAKAROV 1960 Ryta Yevgenivna MAKAROVA 1985 Tetyana Ivanivna MAKAROVA 1971 Yuliya Yevgenivna MAKAROVA 1996 (1) Apartment no. 50 (72.1 sq. m) at 62 Hromovoi St, Mariupol, Donetsk region. (2) Apartment no. 55 (86.2 sq. m) at 60 Hromovoi St, Mariupol, Donetsk region. (3) Apartment no. 56 (37.8 sq. m) at 60 Hromovoi St, Mariupol, Donetsk region. Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 09/04/2022.

On 12/06/2022 the applicants lodged online applications about the destroyed property via the DIIA website.

The passport of Ms Tetyana Makarova with a residence stamp for the apartment (2); the passport of Mr Yevgen Makarov; residence certificate issued in respect of Mr Yevgen Makarov indicating another address in Mariupol dated 06/03/2018; the passport of Ms Ryta Makarova; the passport of Ms Yuliya Makarova; title documents (for the apartment (1) which is owned by Ms Yuliya Makarova and Ms Ryta Makarova jointly - extract from the real estate register dated 15/01/2004; technical passport dated 15/01/2004; for the apartment (2) which is owned by all applicants jointly – ownership registration certificate dated 04/02/1998; for the apartment (3) which is owned by Mr Yevgen and Ms Tetyana Makarova jointly - extract from the real estate register dated 15/05/2018); photos of the destroyed property (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble residential buildings; few walls left; no windows left; traces of burning and soot on the external facade); screenshots of the online applications about the destroyed property submitted via the DIIA website on 12/06/2022; residence permit issued in France in respect of Ms Yuliya Makarova on 01/12/2021; temporary protection certificates issued in France in respect of Ms Tetyana Makarova and Mr Yevgen Makarov on 19/04/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - Mr Yevgen Makarov and Ms Tetyana Makarova complained that they had been forced to flee their home in Mariupol, Donetsk region, and relocate to Strasbourg, France (temporary protection certificates issued in France on 19/04/2022). 33901/24 03/08/2022 Oleksandr Viktorovych LEPIN 1971 Apartment no. 212 (76.7 sq. m) at 18 Novorosiiska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by fire as a result of artillery shelling on 05/04/2022. The applicant’s passport; title documents (the applicant owns ½ share in the apartment – purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 23/04/2013); photos of the destroyed property (completely burnt down and reduced to rubble residential building; no windows left; debris in the yard; explosion holes in the external facade); envelope with the address in Odesa, Odesa region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that he had been forced to flee his home in Mariupol on 05/04/2022, and relocate to Odesa, Odesa region (envelope with an address in Odesa region). 33916/24 23/08/2022 Lyudmyla Petrivna TERTYCHNA 1964 Private house (83.5 sq. m) at 43 Popova St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 01/04/2022. On 19/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (the applicant owns 2/3 share in the apartment - technical passport dated 23/09/2022; inheritance certificate and extract from the real estate register dated 17/09/2019); photos of the destroyed private house (completely burnt down and reduced to rubble; room covered in rubble; burnt down furniture; explosion holes in the walls; destroyed external facade of the residential building; no windows left); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 22/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 19/08/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation without a date; IDP certificate dated 20/06/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and her statements, which she was forced to abandon on 01/04/2022 and relocate to Kyiv (IDP certificate dated 20/06/2022). 34895/24 31/08/2022 Yevgen Valeriyovyh LUPINOV 1979 Apartment no. 20 (45.8 sq. m) at 15 Azovstalska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly damaged by a missile strike on 20/04/2022. On 23/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (ownership certificate and extract from the real estate register, both dated 02/12/2005; deed of gift and extract from the real estate register, both dated 18/06/2014); photos of the destroyed property (completely destroyed residential building; destroyed windows and balconies; traces of fire on the facade; walls damaged by shrapnel; damaged furniture); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 24/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 23/08/2022; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 30/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 22/06/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in his passport and statements, which he was forced to abandon on 24/04/2022, and relocate to Kyiv region (IDP certificate dated 22/06/2022). 34897/24 31/08/2022 Mariya Petrivna LUPINOVA 1978 Apartment no. 19 (45.4 sq. m) at 15 Azovstalska St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly damaged by a missile strike on 20/04/2022. On 24/08/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (ownership certificate, issued as substitute of previous two deeds of gift, and extract from the real estate register, both dated 30/07/2010); photos of the apartment before the destruction, depicting the interior and elements of the applicant’s family life; photos of the destroyed property (residential building completely burnt down; destroyed windows and balconies; traces of fire on the facade; damaged furniture; broken windows; rooms covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 24/08/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on the same date; screenshot of the online application to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 29/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 02/08/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in her passport and statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Kyiv region (IDP certificate dated 02/08/2022). 35181/24 22/08/2022 Oleksiy Mykolayovych SEMENOV 1973 Apartment no. 155 (46.95 sq. m) at 74 Zakhysnykiv Ukrainy Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by fire as a result of artillery shelling on 27/04/2022.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for another apartment in Mariupol; title documents (technical passport dated 27/04/1995; purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 24/04/2018; electricity contract dated 12/12/2017); screenshots from the social media with photos of the apartment after the destruction (completely destroyed and reduced to rubble residential building; few walls left; no windows left; explosion holes in the walls; destroyed roof; yard covered in rubble); envelope with the address in Husiatyn, Ternopil region. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the applicant complained that he had been forced to flee his home in Mariupol, Donetsk region on 27/04/2022, and relocate to Ternopil region (envelope with the address in Husiatyn, Ternopil region).

35299/24 18/07/2022 Denys Mykolayovich LUPONOSOV 1979 (1) Private house at 10 Vzlotna St, Mariupol, Donetsk region; (2) Apartment no. 62 at 2 Azovia district, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by tank shelling between 19/04/2022 and 21/04/2022. The applicant’s passport; residence registration certificate for the apartment dated 15/04/2021; title documents (extract from the real estate register dated 17/12/2007; ownership certificate dated 22/10/2014); photo of the private house prior to its destruction; photos of the destroyed private house (completely burnt down external facade; destroyed roof; destroyed garage with the burnt down vehicle inside; debris in the yard); photo of the damaged residential building; screenshot of a conversation in Telegram chat containing neighbour’s messages about the destruction of the apartment in question without a date; envelope with the address in Lviv, Lviv region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence registration certificate issued on 15/04/2021, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Lviv, Lviv region (envelope with the address in Lviv, Lviv region). 35955/24 06/07/2022 Anna Ruslanivna BOCHAROVA 1984 Andriy Olegovych BOCHAROV 1980 Private house (182.9 sq. m) and outbuildings (vestibule, cellar, inspection pit for a car, residential attic, balcony, toilet, shed, swimming pool, gazebo) at 45B Mizhnarodna St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling on 04/04/2022. On 02/07/2022 Ms Bocharova lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The passport of Ms Bocharova with a residence stamp for the private house; the passport of Mr Bocharov; title documents (joint ownership, each applicant owns 1/2 share in the house - purchase agreement and extract from the real estate register dated 26/11/2020); photos of the house taken prior to its destruction, showing the interior of the house, elements of the applicants’ family life; photos of the destroyed property (completely destroyed roof and internal walls; few walls left; broken windows; traces of burning and soot on the walls; courtyard covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 05/07/2022, confirming the registration of Ms Bocharova’s complaint lodged on 02/07/2022; police reports dated 02/07/2022 and 03/07/2022; police interrogation report dated 05/07/2022; receipts; IDP certificates dated 21/03/2022 and 06/05/2022.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicants’ home as confirmed by the residence stamp in Ms Bocharova’s passport and photos of the house taken prior to its destruction, showing the applicant’s family life, which they were forced to abandon and relocate to Ladyzhyn, Vinnytsia region (IDP certificates dated 21/03/2022 and 06/05/2022). 36142/24 08/07/2022 Igor Leonidovych PAVLYUK 1968 (1) Apartment no. 81 at 87A Myru (Lenina) Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region; (2) Apartment no. 62 at 89 Myru (Lenina) Ave., Mariupol, Donetsk region; (3) Apartment no. 50 at 110 Budivelnykiv Ave, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed by fire as a result of artillery shelling on 16/03/2022.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment 1; title documents (extracts from the real estate register for the three apartments dated 22/10/2009 and 10/09/2009); photos of the destroyed property (residential buildings completely burnt down and reduced to rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 07/07/2022, confirming the complaint lodged by a third party on 14/06/2022, mentioning the applicant’s property and the reference number of his complaint; envelope with the address in Kyiv, Kyiv region. complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment (1) was the applicant’s home as confirmed by a residence stamp in his passport and statements, which he was forced to abandon and relocate to Kyiv (envelope with the address in Kyiv, Kyiv region).

36938/24 18/08/2022 Lyudmyla Oleksandrivna ASAULKA 1957 (1) Private house (105.1 sq. m) and outbuildings at 25 Zhuravelna (previously Shchorsa) St, Mariupol, Donetsk region (destruction); (2) Land plot (0.0747 ha) at 25 Zhuravelna (previously Shchorsa) St, Mariupol, Donetsk region (loss of access) Allegedly destroyed by artillery shelling between 01/04/2022 and 10/04/2022. The applicant learned about the destruction from her neighbour on 20/04/2022. On 28/06/2022 the applicant lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the private house; title documents (the applicant owns 1/2 share in the private house - property certificate dated 10/03/1992; house acceptance certificate of 13/03/1991; ownership certificate for a land plot dated 14/07/2000); screenshot from the Viber application containing a photo of the destroyed house dated 20/04/2022; photos of the destroyed house (destroyed to the ground; no walls left standing); complaint to the Ukrainian police dated 28/06/2022; extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 29/06/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s complaint lodged on 28/06/2022; handwritten complaint to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation dated 07/08/2022; IDP certificate dated 30/03/2022.

complete destruction, loss of access to property Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the house in question was the applicant’s home, as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport and her statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Vasylkivka village, Synelnykove district, Dnipropetrovsk region (IDP certificate dated 30/03/2022). 36986/24 16/07/2022 Valentyna Ivanivna DURYTSKA 1967 Apartment no. 69 (50.8 sq. m) at 39 Latysheva St, Mariupol, Donetsk region Allegedly destroyed as a result of artillery shelling between 01/04/2022 and 06/04/2022. On 30/06/2022 the applicant’s daughter lodged a complaint with the Ukrainian police on her behalf.

The applicant’s passport with a residence stamp for the apartment; title documents (the applicant owns 1/3 share in the apartment – ownership certificate dated 20/02/1995; technical passport without a date); photos of the apartment prior to its destruction, showing the scenes of everyday life, interior and personal belongings; photos of the apartment after the destruction (completely burnt down and reduced to rubble; few walls left; traces of burning and soot on the external walls; yard covered in rubble); extract from the register of pre-trial investigations dated 03/07/2022, confirming the registration of the applicant’s daughter’s complaint lodged on 30/06/2022; witness statement without a date; envelope with the address in Horodyshche, Khmelnytskyi region.

complete destruction Art. 8 (1) - flight from one’s home as a result of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine - the apartment in question was the applicant’s home as confirmed by the residence stamp in her passport, photos of the apartment prior to its destruction depicting elements of the interior, and her statements, which she was forced to abandon and relocate to Horodyshche, Khmelnytskyi region (envelope with the address in Horodyshche, Khmelnytskyi region).