BARRICELLA AND OTHERS v. ITALY

BARRICELLA AND OTHERS v. ITALY (CtEDO, 2022)

PRIMEI DECIZIE DECIZIE Nr. 39637/21 Biagio BARRICELLA împotriva Italiei și 71 de alte cereri (a se vedea tabelul anexat) Curtea Europeană a Drepturilor Omului (prima secțiune), ședința la 20 octombrie 2022 în calitate de comitet compus din: Krzysztof Wojtyczek , Președintele Erik Wennerström, Lorraine Schembri Orland , judecători și Viktoriya Maradudina , grefier adjunct al secțiunii interioare , Având în vedere cererile depuse mai sus la diferitele date indicate în tabelul anexat, având în vedere declarația depusă de Guvernul contestat care solicită Curții să ia cererile din lista cazurilor, după deliberare, hotărăște după cum urmează: FACTE ȘI PROCEDIU Lista reclamanților este prezentată în tabelul anexat. Reclamanții au fost reprezentați de Biondi Pasquale , un avocat care practică în Telese Terme . Plângerile reclamanților în temeiul articolului 6 § 1 din Convenție și al articolului 1 din Protocolul nr. 1 privind neexecutarea sau întârziarea aplicării deciziilor interne au fost comunicate guvernului italian („Guvernul”). Având în vedere subiectul similar al cererilor, Curtea consideră oportun să le examineze în comun într-o singură decizie. Guvernul a informat Curtea că a propus să facă o declarație unilaterală în vederea soluționării problemelor legate de aceste plângeri și a solicitat, în continuare, Curtea să elimine cererile în conformitate cu art. 37 din Convenție. Guvernul a recunoscut neexecuția sau întârziarea executării deciziilor interne, care au oferit reclamanților să plătească sumele detaliate în declarație și a invitat Curtea să scoată cererile din lista cazurilor în conformitate cu art. 37 alineatul (c) din convenție. Declarația se citește după cum urmează: „Guvernul italian recunoaște că reclamanții au fost supuși încălcărilor convenționale așa cum susțin, în conformitate cu principiile exprimate de Curtea Drepturilor Omului în acest context. Guvernul, cu această declarație, oferă fiecărui solicitant suma de € 12.500 ca compensare pentru orice prejudicii morale și 250 € pentru a acoperi orice costuri și cheltuieli, plus orice impozit care poate fi taxat reclamantului pentru aceste sume. Guvernul consideră că această declarație, care conține recunoașterea încălcărilor menționate mai sus și prevederea unei restituiri, reprezintă o compensație adecvată pentru reclamant, în conformitate cu jurisprudența Curții în această privință. .... Guvernul va continua să plătească sumele oferite cu prezenta declarație în termen de trei luni de la data notificării hotărârii luate de Curte de a elimina cazul din lista sa de cauze. În cazul în care aceste sume nu se plătesc în termenul de trei luni, guvernul se angajează să plătească dobânzi simple pe acestea, de la expirarea perioadei respective până la decontare, la o rată egală cu rata marginală de creditare a Băncii Centrale Europene în timpul perioadei implicite plus trei puncte procentuale. În plus, Guvernul se angajează să asigure executarea deciziilor interne luate în considerare în aceste cazuri în aceeași perioadă de trei luni și să plătească orice costuri ale procedurii interne de aplicare. Plata și executarea deciziilor în acest caz vor constitui rezoluția finală a cazului.” Reclamanții au fost trimiși termenii declarației unilaterale ale Guvernului cu câteva săptămâni înainte de data prezentei decizii. Curtea nu a primit un răspuns din partea reclamanților care acceptă termenii declarației. Curtea observă că art. 37 § § § § c) îi permite să scoată un caz din lista sa dacă: „... din orice alt motiv stabilit de Curte, nu mai este justificat să continue examinarea cererii”. Astfel, aceasta poate elimina cererile în temeiul articolului 37 § 1 litera (c) pe baza unei declarații unilaterale de către un guvern contestat, chiar dacă reclamanții doresc să continue examinarea cazurilor (a se vedea, în special, Tahsin Acar c. Turcia) Hotărârea (obiecții preliminare) [GC], nr. 26307/95, §§ 77, CEDO 2003-VI). Curtea a stabilit o jurisprudență clară și extensă privind plângerile referitoare la neexecuția sau aplicarea întârziere a deciziilor interne (a se vedea, de exemplu, Ventorino c. Italia, nr. 357/07, 17 mai 2011, De Trana c. Italia, nr. 64215/01, 16 octombrie 2007, Nicola Silvestri c. Italia, nr. 16861/02, 9 iunie 2009, și Antonetto c. Italia, nr. 15918/89, 20 iulie 2000). Observarea admiterilor conținute în declarația guvernului, precum și a sumelor de compensare propuse – care sunt în concordanță cu sumele acordate în cazuri similare – Curtea consideră că nu mai este justificată continuarea examinării cererilor (art. 37 § § § c)). Având în vedere considerentele de mai sus, Curtea este convinsă că respectarea drepturilor omului, astfel cum este definită în Convenție și în Protocolurile sale, nu impune ca aceasta să continue examinarea cererilor (art. 37 § în amendă În sfârșit, Curtea subliniază că, în cazul în care Guvernul nu respectă termenii declarației lor unilaterale, cererile pot fi restaurate pe listă în conformitate cu art. 37 § 2 din Convenție (a se vedea Josipović c. Serbia (dec.), nr. 18369/07, 4 martie 2008). Având în vedere cele de mai sus, este oportun să se scoată cazurile din listă. Din aceste motive, Curtea, în unanimitate, Decide să se alăture cererilor; ia act de termenele declarației guvernului contestat și de modalitățile de asigurare a respectării întreprinderilor menționate în acest articol; decide să scoată cererile din lista sa de cazuri în conformitate cu art. 37 § litera (c) din Convenție. Adoptate în limba engleză și notificate în scris la 10 noiembrie 2022. Viktoriya Maradudina Krzysztof Wojtyczek Președintele adjunct al grefierului interimar APENDIX Lista cererilor care depun plângeri în temeiul articolului 6 § 1 din Convenția și art. 1 din Protocolul nr. 1 (neexecuție sau întârziere de aplicare a deciziilor interne) Nr. cerere nr. Data introducerii Denumirea reclamantului Anul nașterii Hotărârea internă relevantă Data primirii declarației guvernamentale Data primirii observațiilor reclamantului, dacă este vreo 39637/21 02/08/2021 Biagio BARRICELLA 1971 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4320/2011, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4970/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2780/2014, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4788/2016, 10/10/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 11/2018, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1524/220, 08/05/2020 17/06/202 27/07/2022 39641/21 02/08/2021 Tiziano BARRICELLA 1970 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4325/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4969/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2687/2014, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2804/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 12/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1522/2020, 13/05/20 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39643/21 02/08/2021 Diomede BOSCO 1969 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4315/2011, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4971/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2682/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2798/2016, 07/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 13/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1506/2020, 04/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39648/21 02/08/2021 Vincenzo CARFORA 1969 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5019/2011, 17/10/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4974/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2788/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2795/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 14/2018, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1507/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39649/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4025/2011, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4978/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2600/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4786/2016, 26/10/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 15/2018, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1521/202020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39650/21 02/08/2021 Giuseppe Antonio CASERTA 1974 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4024/2011, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4979/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2794/2016, 14/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 16/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1508/2020, 04/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39651/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4313/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4977/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2796/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 17/2018, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1504/2020, 04/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39652/21 02/08/2021 Grazia Maria CENICOLA 1967 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2803/2015, 05/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2812/2016, 07/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 18/2018, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1530/2020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39653/21 02/08/2021 Michele CIERVO 1955 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2956/2015, 14/07/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2817/2016, 07/06/2016 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39654/21 02/08/2021 Veturia CIVITILLO 1961 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2753/2015, 10/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4785/2016, 10/10/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1503/2020, 04/05/20 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39655/21 02/08/2021 Antonio DE CAPUA 1965 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4324/2011, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4983/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2601/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2784/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 19/2018, 25/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1501/2020, 04/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39656/21 02/08/2021 Nicola DE CARLO 1968 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4332/2011, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4985/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento 4787/2016, 07/10/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 20/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1525/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39657/21 02/08/2021 Luigi DEL NIGRO 1963 Tribunalul de District RG 4914/2013, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2781/2016, 13/06/2016 Curtea de district Benevento RG 21/2018, 12/01/2018 Curtea de district Benevento RG 1537/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39658/21 02/08/2021 Bruno DI CROSTA 1965 Curtea de district Benevento RG 4046/2016, 25/08/2016 Curtea de district Benevento RG 22/2018, 30/01/2018 Curtea de district Benevento RG 1529/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39659/21 02/08/2021 Carmine DI MEOLA 1967 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4316/2011, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4987/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2602/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2780/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 23/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1515/2020, 07/05/20 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39660/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Fulvio DI NOLA 1964 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 3978/2015, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 2818/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 474/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 1520/2020, 08/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39661/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 4317/2011, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 4991/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul districtual Benevento RG 2683/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul districtului Benevento RG 2793/2016, 07/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 24/2018, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1514/2020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39662/21 02/08/2021 Alessandro FORMOSA SALA 1964 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4318/2011, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4992/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2604/2014, 30/05/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2778/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 26/2018, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1513/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39663/21 02/08/2021 Carlo Rosario FUCCI 1960 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4312/2011, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4994/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2782/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2772/2016, 31/05/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 27/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1527/2020, 07/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39664/21 02/08/2021 Rocco Antonio GRANATIELLO 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 3975/2015, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4790/2016, 10/10/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 28/2018, 25/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1518/2020, 13/05/20 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39665/21 02/08/2021 Damiano ICOLARI 1962 Curtea de judecată Benevento nr. 727/12, 20/12/2012 Curtea de judecată Benevento RG 5931/2016, 02/12/2016 Curtea de judecată Benevento RG 29/2018, 25/01/2018 Curtea de judecată Benevento RG 1500/202020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39666/21 02/08/2021 Alberto LAUDANNA 1968 Curtea de judecată de judecată nr. 790/2013, 05/11/2013 Curtea de judecată Benevento RG 2771/2016, 14/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 30/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1534/2020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39667/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento 1965 Tribunalul de District RG 4328/2011, 09/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 499/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2784/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4789/2016, 26/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento RG 31/2018, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento RG 1502/2020, 04/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39668/21 02/08/2021 Enzo MARRA 1963 Curtea de District Benevento RG 4336/2011 02/09/2011 Curtea de District Benevento RG 5001/2012, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento RG 2605/2014, 30/05/2014 Curtea de District Benevento RG 2770/2016, 31/05/2016 Curtea de District Benevento RG 32/2018, 30/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento RG 1523/2020, 07/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39669/21 02/08/2021 Antonio MARRO 1979 Curtea de District Benevento RG 3815/2011, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District Benevento injuncție Ordinea de judecată n. 5/2013, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento RG 1543/2020, 07/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39670/21 02/08/2021 Giano MASOTTA 1961 Curtea de District Benevento RG 3976/2015, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2809/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 34/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1517/2020, 15/05/20 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39671/21 02/08/2021 Simone MASTRANTUONO 1978 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 3814/2011, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5002/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2779/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 35/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1526/2020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39672/21 02/08/2021 Elvio MORONE 1969 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4321/2011, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5004/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2777/2014, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2769/2016, 14/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 36/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1505/2020, 13/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39673/21 02/08/2021 Adalgisa NAPOLITANO 1963 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2838/2015, 18/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2816/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 37/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1533/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39674/21 02/08/2021 Michele PENGUE 1966 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2913/2015, 18/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2813/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 38/2018, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1509/2020, 15/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39675/21 02/08/2021 Gerardo Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4917/2013, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2768/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 39/2018, 26/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento RG 1535/2020, 07/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39676/21 02/08/2021 Michele RICCIARDI 1961 Curtea de District Benevento RG 3822/2011, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District Benevento RG 5011/2012, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento RG 2609/2014, 03/06/2014 Curtea de District Benevento RG 2766/2016, 31/05/2016 Curtea de District Benevento RG 40/2018, 26/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento RG 1528/2020, 08/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39677/21 02/08/2021 Nicola RICCIO 1970 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 3823/2011, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5010/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2792/2014, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2765/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 41/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1510/20220, 13/05/2017/06/222 27/07/2022 39678/21 02/08/2021 Alessandro SERAPIDE 1976 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4314/2011, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5014/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2688/2014, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2750/2016, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 42/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1512/2020, 08/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39679/21 02/08/2021 Antonio STARITA 1962 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 4918/2013, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2749/2016, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 43/2018, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1536/20220, 08/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39680/21 02/08/2021 Antonio TIZZANI 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 3828/2011, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 5019/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2611/2014, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 2751/2016, 01/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 44/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento RG 1516/2020, 08/05/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39773/21 02/08/2021 Anna Rita AVERSANO 1965 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2251/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3803/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4968/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2685/14, 30/05/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4195/15, 17/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3046/16, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39775/21 02/08/2021 Giuseppe BOSCO 1964 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4319/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4972/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2599/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5954/15, 21/05/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3048/16, 19/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39776/21/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3805/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4976/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2781/14, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5958/15, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3050/16, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 3977/21 02/08/2021 Mario CARUSO 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4311/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4975/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2681/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4196/15, 16/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3049/16, 02/12/2019 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 4412/14, 08/04/220 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39778/21 02/08/2021 Vincenzo COZZOLINO 1963 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4980/2012, 08/01/2013 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 1252/2014, 03/10/2019 Tribunalul de District de Benevento R.G. 3051/2019, 19/12/2019 Tribunalul de District de Benevento R.G. 2119/2017, 16/01/2020 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39779/21 02/08/2021 Rosaria DE MIZIO 1969 Tribunalul de District de Benevento R.G. 4397/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District de Benevento R.G. 4981/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2786/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3053/16, 19/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39780/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. necunoscut, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4982/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2787/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5959/15, 21/05/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3052/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39781/21 02/08/2021 Massimo DI DOMENICO 1969 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3807/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4988/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3054/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39782/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4986/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6139/16, 15/12/2016 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 1250/14, 03/10/2019 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 3055/16, 05/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39783/21 02/08/2021 Antonietta ESPOSITO 1958 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 4323/11, 05/09/2011 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 4989/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 2779/14, 05/06/2014 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 5945/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3056/16, 19/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39784/21 02/08/2021 Angela FALLARINO 1964 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3810/11, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4990/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2603/14, 09/06/2014 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5957/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3057/16, 19/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39785/21 02/08/2021 Carmine FRATTASI 1968 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4993/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4310/11, 26/09/2011 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2785/14 09/06/2014 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5948/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3058/16, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39786/21 02/08/2021 Curtea de District Vittorio IULIANO 1959 R.G. 4312/11, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4995/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2783/14, 09/06/2014 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 752/19, 10/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39787/21 02/08/2021 Ida LEPORE 1962 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 398/2011, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 4998/2012, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District de Benevento R.G. 2684/2014, 30/05/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5952/2015, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3095/2016, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39788/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Gerardo MIGNONE 1967 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3813/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5005/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2606/14, 30/05/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5947/15, 21/05/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3097/16, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 3978/21 02/08/2021 Raffaele MIGNONE 1966 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3916/2011, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5003/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2776/2014, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6501/2015, 20/04/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3096/2016, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39790/21 02/08/2021 Antonio PETRELLA 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3918/2011, 22/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5006/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2607/2014, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5949/2015, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3059/2016, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39791/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Nuno R.G. 3918/2011, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5007/2012, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2608/2014, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3061/2016, 05/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39792/21 02/08/2021 Antonello RINALDI 1962 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3821/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5099/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2789/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5946/15, 29/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3099/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39793/21 02/08/2021 Fabrizio RINALDI 1965 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5008/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2686/2014, 30/05/2014 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 6502/15, 29/01/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3098/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39794/21 02/08/2021 Rossana ROTILI 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3817/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5012/12, 12/12/2012 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 804/17, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3060/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39795/21 02/08/2021 Antonio RUSO 1964 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3824/2011, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5013/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2790/2014, 09/06/2014 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 6503/2015, 16/04/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3101/2016, 05/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39796/21 02/08/2021 Angela SCOCCA 1960 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3226/11, 11/07/2011 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5016/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2773/14, 17/06/2014 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 6504/15, 29/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3102/16, 02/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39797/21 02/08/2021 Anna TASCIONE 1962 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3829/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5020/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2610/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5950/15, 21/05/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3062/16, 25/02/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 3979/98/21 02/08/2021 Antonio VILLANI 1956 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4691/11, 21/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5022/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2778/14, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6140/16, 14/12/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3063/16, 05/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 3979/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Enrico VOLPERINI 1959 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3979/15, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2117/17, 12/12/2019 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3103/16, 19/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39800/21 02/08/2021 Alberto SIGNORIELLO 1961 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 8281/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5015/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1922/17, 19/04/2017 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3470/17, 12/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39801/21 02/08/2021 Assunta SPANANEO 1964 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 3825/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5017/12, 08/01/2013 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39802/21 02/08/2021 Luigi ZITANI 1961 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5023/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4334/11, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2791/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5951/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de Apel a Naples R.G. 754/2019, 10/12/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39806/21 02/08/2021 Mohamed BOUDALI 1954 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 3804/11, 19/07/2011 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 4973/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1080/17, 17/12/2018 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 39807/21 02/08/2021 Curtea de District a Casei Mario DE IANNI 1991 Fiorella DE IANNI 1996 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 3809/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4984/2012, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5623/2011, 10/06/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1921/2017, 28/04/2017 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3471/2017, 30/09/2019 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 40257/21 29/07/2021 Casa Michelina LAUDANNA 1956 Patrizia SPINIELLO 1987 Roberta SPINIELLO 1990 Emilio SPINIELLO 1992 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4331/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5018/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 484/2015, 18/03/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1063/2015, 23/03/2015 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 40258/21 29/07/2021 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5034/13, 07/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 817/15, 09/03/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1061/15, 16/04/2015 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 40259/21 29/07/2021 Silvana IULIANO 1955 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4327/11, 05/09/2011 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4996/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 483/2015, 17/02/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1060/2015, 12/03/2015 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 40260/21 29/07/2021 Piero MANCINI 1957 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2270/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4335/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4997/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 818/15, 10/03/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1062/15, 12/03/2015 17/06/2022 27/07/2022 40261/21 29/07/2021 Tribunalul de District Gerarda VERDINO 1968 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5021/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 485/2015, 12/02/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1064/2015, 12/03/2015 17/06/2022 27/07/2022

FIRST SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 39637/21

Biagio BARRICELLA

against Italy

and 71 other applications

(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 20

October 2022 as a Committee composed of:

Krzysztof Wojtyczek

, President

,

Erik Wennerström,

Lorraine Schembri Orland

, judges

,

and Viktoriya Maradudina,

Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having regard to the declaration submitted by the respondent Government requesting the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.

The applicants were represented by

Biondi Pasquale

, a lawyer practising in Telese Terme.

The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article

1 of Protocol No. 1 concerning the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”).

THE LAW

Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

After unsuccessful friendly-settlement negotiations, the Government informed the Court that they proposed to make a unilateral declaration with a view to resolving the issues raised by these complaints. They further requested the Court to strike out the applications in accordance with Article

37 of the Convention.

The Government acknowledged the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions. They offered to pay the applicants the amounts detailed in the declaration and invited the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases in accordance with Article

37 §

1

(c) of the Convention. The declaration read as follows:

“The Italian Government recognize that the Applicants were subjected to the conventional violations as they claim, according to the principles expressed by the Court of Human Rights in this context.

The Government, with this declaration, offer to each Applicant the sum of €

12,500 as compensation for any non-pecuniary damage, and € 250 to cover any costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable to the Applicant on these amounts.

The Government believe that this declaration, containing the acknowledgement of the abovementioned violations and the provision of a refund, represents an adequate compensation for the claimant, according to the jurisprudence of the Court on the matter.

....

The Government will proceed to pay the sums offered with the present declaration within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court to strike the case out of its list of cases. In the event of failure to pay these sums within the said three-month period, the Government undertake to pay simple interest on them, from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.

Further, the Government undertake to ensure the enforcement of the domestic decisions under consideration in these cases within the same three-month period, and to pay any costs of the domestic enforcement proceedings.

The payment and the enforcement of the decisions in the case will constitute the final resolution of the case.”

The applicants were sent the terms of the Government’s unilateral declaration several weeks before the date of this decision. The Court has not received a response from the applicants accepting the terms of the declaration.

The Court observes that Article

37 §

1

(c) enables it to strike a case out of its list if:

“... for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application”.

Thus, it may strike out applications under Article

37 §

1 (c) on the basis of a unilateral declaration by a respondent Government even if the applicants wish the examination of the cases to be continued (see, in particular, the

Tahsin Acar v.

Turkey

judgment (preliminary objections) [GC], no.

26307/95, §§

75

‑

77, ECHR 2003-VI).

The Court has established clear and extensive case-law concerning complaints relating to the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions (see, for example,

Ventorino v. Italy,

no. 357/07, 17 May 2011,

De Trana v. Italy,

no. 64215/01, 16 October 2007,

Nicola Silvestri v.

Italy,

no. 16861/02, 9 June 2009, and

Antonetto v. Italy,

no. 15918/89, 20

July 2000).

Noting the admissions contained in the Government’s declaration as well as the amounts of compensation proposed – which are consistent with the amounts awarded in similar cases – the Court considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications (Article

37 §

1

(c)).

In the light of the above considerations, the Court is satisfied that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications (Article

37 §

1

in fine

).

Finally, the Court emphasises that, should the Government fail to comply with the terms of their unilateral declaration, the applications may be restored to the list in accordance with Article

37 §

2 of the Convention (see

Josipović v.

Serbia

(dec.), no.

18369/07, 4

March 2008).

In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides

to join the applications;

Takes note

of the terms of the respondent Government’s declaration and of the arrangements for ensuring compliance with the undertakings referred to therein;

Decides

to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article

37 §

1

(c) of the Convention.

Done in English and notified in writing on 10 November 2022.

Viktoriya Maradudina

Krzysztof Wojtyczek

Acting Deputy Registrar

President

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article

6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol no. 1

(non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions)

No.

Application no.

Date of introduction

Applicant’s name

Year of birth

Relevant domestic decision

Date of receipt of

Government’s declaration

Date of receipt of applicant’s comments, if any

39637/21

02/08/2021

Biagio BARRICELLA

1971

Benevento District Court

RG 4320/2011,

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4970/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2780/2014,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 4788/2016,

10/10/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 11/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1524/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39641/21

02/08/2021

Tiziano BARRICELLA

1970

Benevento District Court

RG 4325/11,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4969/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2687/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2804/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 12/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1522/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39643/21

02/08/2021

Diomede BOSCO

1969

Benevento District Court

RG 4315/2011,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4971/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2682/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2798/2016,

07/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 13/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1506/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39648/21

02/08/2021

Vincenzo CARFORA

1969

Benevento District Court

RG 5019/2011,

17/10/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4974/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2788/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2795/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 14/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1507/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39649/21

02/08/2021

Emilio CASARIO

1976

Benevento District Court

RG 4025/2011,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4978/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2600/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 4786/2016,

26/10/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 15/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1521/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39650/21

02/08/2021

Giuseppe Antonio CASERTA

1974

Benevento District Court

RG 4024/2011,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4979/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2794/2016,

14/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 16/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1508/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39651/21

02/08/2021

Assunta CASTIELLO

1958

Benevento District Court

RG 4313/11,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4977/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2796/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 17/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1504/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39652/21

02/08/2021

Grazia Maria CENICCOLA

1967

Benevento District Court

RG 2803/2015,

05/06/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2812/2016,

07/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 18/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1530/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39653/21

02/08/2021

Michele CIERVO

1955

Benevento District Court

RG 2956/2015,

14/07/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2817/2016,

07/06/2016

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39654/21

02/08/2021

Veturia CIVITILLO

1961

Benevento District Court

RG 2753/2015,

10/06/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 4785/2016,

10/10/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 1503/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39655/21

02/08/2021

Antonio DE CAPUA

1965

Benevento District Court

RG 4324/2011,

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4983/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2601/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2784/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 19/2018,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1501/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39656/21

02/08/2021

Nicola DE CARLO

1968

Benevento District Court

RG 4332/2011,

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4985/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG

4787/2016, 07/10/2016

Benevento District Court RG

20/2018, 30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1525/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39657/21

02/08/2021

Luigi DEL NIGRO

1963

Benevento District Court

RG 4914/2013,

05/11/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2781/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 21/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1537/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39658/21

02/08/2021

Bruno DI CROSTA

1965

Benevento District Court

RG 4046/2016,

25/08/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 22/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1529/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39659/21

02/08/2021

Carmine DI MEOLA

1967

Benevento District Court

RG 4316/2011,

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4987/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2602/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2780/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 23/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1515/2020,

07/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39660/21

02/08/2021

Fulvio DI NOLA

1964

Benevento District Court

RG 3978/2015,

25/08/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2818/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 474/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1520/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39661/21

02/08/2021

Vincenzo FERRARO

1959

Benevento District Court

RG 4317/2011,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4991/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2683/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2793/2016,

07/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 24/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1514/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39662/21

02/08/2021

Alessandro FORMOSA SALA

1964

Benevento District Court

RG 4318/2011,

26/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4992/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2604/2014,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2778/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 26/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1513/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39663/21

02/08/2021

Carlo Rosario FUCCI

1960

Benevento District Court

RG 4312/2011,

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4994/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2782/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2772/2016,

31/05/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 27/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1527/2020,

07/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39664/21

02/08/2021

Rocco Antonio GRANATIELLO

1959

Benevento District Court

RG 3975/2015,

25/08/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 4790/2016,

10/10/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 28/2018,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1518/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39665/21

02/08/2021

Damiano ICOLARI

1962

Benevento District Court

injunction order n. 727/12, 20/12/2012

Benevento District Court

RG 5931/2016,

02/12/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 29/2018,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1500/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39666/21

02/08/2021

Alberto LAUDANNA

1968

Benevento District Court

injunction order n. 790/2013, 05/11/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2771/2016,

14/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 30/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1534/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39667/21

02/08/2021

Pasquale LOMBARDO

1965

Benevento District Court

RG 4328/2011,

09/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 4999/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2784/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 4789/2016,

26/10/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 31/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1502/2020,

04/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39668/21

02/08/2021

Enzo MARRA

1963

Benevento District Court

RG 4336/2011

02/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5001/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2605/2014,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2770/2016,

31/05/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 32/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1523/2020,

07/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39669/21

02/08/2021

Antonio MARRO

1979

Benevento District Court

RG 3815/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

injunction order n. 5/2013, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 1543/2020,

07/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39670/21

02/08/2021

Giano MASOTTA

1961

Benevento District Court

RG 3976/2015,

25/08/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2809/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 34/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1517/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39671/21

02/08/2021

Simone MASTRANTUONO

1978

Benevento District Court

RG 3814/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5002/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2779/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 35/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1526/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39672/21

02/08/2021

Elvio MORONE

1969

Benevento District Court

RG 4321/2011,

26/08/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5004/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2777/2014,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2769/2016,

14/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 36/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1505/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39673/21

02/08/2021

Adalgisa NAPOLITANO

1963

Benevento District Court

RG 2838/2015,

18/06/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2816/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 37/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1533/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39674/21

02/08/2021

Michele PENGUE

1966

Benevento District Court

RG 2913/2015,

18/06/2015

Benevento District Court

RG 2813/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 38/2018,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1509/2020,

15/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39675/21

02/08/2021

Gerardo PISTONE

1961

Benevento District Court

RG 4917/2013,

05/11/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2768/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 39/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1535/2020,

07/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39676/21

02/08/2021

Michele RICCIARDI

1961

Benevento District Court

RG 3822/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5011/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2609/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2766/2016,

31/05/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 40/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1528/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39677/21

02/08/2021

Nicola RICCIO

1970

Benevento District Court

RG 3823/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5010/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2792/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2765/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 41/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1510/2020,

13/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39678/21

02/08/2021

Alessandro SERAPIDE

1976

Benevento District Court

RG 4314/2011,

26/09/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5014/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2688/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2750/2016,

06/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 42/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1512/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39679/21

02/08/2021

Antonio STARITA

1962

Benevento District Court

RG 4918/2013,

05/11/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2749/2016,

13/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 43/2018,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1536/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39680/21

02/08/2021

Antonio TIZZANI

1959

Benevento District Court

RG 3828/2011,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

RG 5019/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

RG 2611/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

RG 2751/2016,

01/06/2016

Benevento District Court

RG 44/2018,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court

RG 1516/2020,

08/05/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39773/21

02/08/2021

Anna Rita AVERSANO

1965

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2251/11,

09/06/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3803/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4968/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2685/14,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4195/15,

17/09/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3046/16,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39775/21

02/08/2021

Giuseppe BOSCO

1964

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4319/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4972/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2599/14,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5954/15,

21/05/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3048/16,

19/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39776/21

02/08/2021

Assunta CAPITANIO

1961

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3805/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4976/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2781/14,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5958/15,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3050/16,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39777/21

02/08/2021

Mario CARUSO

1959

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4311/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4975/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2681/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4196/15,

16/09/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3049/16,

02/12/2019

Naples Court of Appeal

R.G. 4412/14,

08/04/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39778/21

02/08/2021

Vincenzo COZZOLINO

1963

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4980/2012,

08/01/2013

Naples Court of Appeal

R.G. 1252/2014,

03/10/2019

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3051/2019,

19/12/2019

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2119/2017,

16/01/2020

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39779/21

02/08/2021

Rosaria DE MIZIO

1969

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4397/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4981/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2786/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3053/16,

19/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39780/21

02/08/2021

Diamante DE PIERRO

1954

Benevento District Court

R.G. unknown,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4982/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2787/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5959/15,

21/05/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3052/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39781/21

02/08/2021

Massimo DI DOMENICO

1969

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3807/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4988/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3054/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39782/21

02/08/2021

Pompeo DI PINTO

1960

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4986/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6139/16,

15/12/2016

Naples Court of Appeal

R.G. 1250/14,

03/10/2019

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3055/16,

05/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39783/21

02/08/2021

Antonietta ESPOSITO

1958

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4323/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4989/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2779/14,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5945/15,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3056/16,

19/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39784/21

02/08/2021

Angela FALLARINO

1964

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3810/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4990/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2603/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5957/15,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3057/16,

19/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39785/21

02/08/2021

Carmine FRATTASI

1968

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4993/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4310/11,

26/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2785/14

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5948/15,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3058/16,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39786/21

02/08/2021

Vittorio IULIANO

1959

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4312/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4995/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2783/14,

09/06/2014

Naples Court of Appeal

R.G. 752/19,

10/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39787/21

02/08/2021

Ida LEPORE

1962

Benevento District Court

R.G. 398/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4998/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2684/2014,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5952/2015,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3095/2016,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39788/21

02/08/2021

Gerardo MIGNONE

1967

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3813/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5005/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2606/14,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5947/15,

21/05/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3097/16,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39789/21

02/08/2021

Raffaele MIGNONE

1966

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3916/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5003/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2776/2014,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6501/2015,

20/04/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3096/2016,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39790/21

02/08/2021

Antonio PETRELLA

1959

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3918/2011,

22/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5006/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2607/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5949/2015,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3059/2016,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39791/21

02/08/2021

Nunzio RETTORE

1958

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3918/2011,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5007/2012,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2608/2014,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3061/2016,

05/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39792/21

02/08/2021

Antonello RINALDI

1962

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3821/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5099/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2789/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5946/15,

29/01/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3099/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39793/21

02/08/2021

Fabrizio RINALDI

1965

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5008/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2686/2014,

30/05/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6502/15,

29/01/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3098/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39794/21

02/08/2021

Rossana ROTILI

1959

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3817/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5012/12,

12/12/2012

Benevento District Court

R.G. 804/17,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3060/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39795/21

02/08/2021

Antonio RUSSO

1964

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3824/2011,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5013/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2790/2014,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6503/2015,

16/04/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3101/2016,

05/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39796/21

02/08/2021

Angela SCOCCA

1960

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3226/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5016/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2773/14,

17/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6504/15,

29/01/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3102/16,

02/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39797/21

02/08/2021

Anna TASCIONE

1962

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3829/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5020/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2610/14,

03/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5950/15,

21/05/2018

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3062/16,

25/02/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39798/21

02/08/2021

Antonio VILLANI

1956

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4691/11,

21/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5022/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2778/14,

05/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 6140/16,

14/12/2016

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3063/16,

05/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39799/21

02/08/2021

Enrico VOLPERINI

1959

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3979/15,

25/08/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2117/17,

12/12/2019

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3103/16,

19/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39800/21

02/08/2021

Alberto SIGNORIELLO

1961

Benevento District Court

R.G. 8281/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5015/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1922/17,

19/04/2017

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3470/17,

12/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39801/21

02/08/2021

Assunta SPARANEO

1964

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3825/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5017/12,

08/01/2013

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39802/21

02/08/2021

Luigi ZITANI

1961

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5023/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4334/11,

26/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2791/14,

09/06/2014

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5951/15,

12/07/2018

Naples Court of Appeal

R.G. 754/2019,

10/12/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39806/21

02/08/2021

Mohamed BOUDALI

1954

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3804/11,

19/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4973/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1080/17,

17/12/2018

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

39807/21

02/08/2021

Household

Mario DE IANNI

1991

Fiorella DE IANNI

1996

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3809/11,

11/07/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4984/2012,

08/01/2013

Benevento District court

R.G. 5623/2011,

10/06/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1921/2017,

28/04/2017

Benevento District Court

R.G. 3471/2017,

30/09/2019

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

40257/21

29/07/2021

Household

Michelina LAUDANNA

1956

Patrizia SPINIELLO

1987

Roberta SPINIELLO

1990

Emilio SPINIELLO

1992

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4331/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5018/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 484/2015,

18/03/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1063/2015,

23/03/2015

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

40258/21

29/07/2021

Concetta FERRARO

1976

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5034/13,

07/11/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 817/15,

09/03/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1061/15,

16/04/2015

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

40259/21

29/07/2021

Silvana IULIANO

1955

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4327/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4996/12,

15/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 483/2015,

17/02/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1060/2015,

12/03/2015

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

40260/21

29/07/2021

Piero MANCINI

1957

Benevento District Court

R.G. 2270/11,

30/06/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4335/11,

05/09/2011

Benevento District Court

R.G. 4997/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 818/15,

10/03/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1062/15,

12/03/2015

17/06/2022

27/07/2022

40261/21

29/07/2021

Gerarda VERDINO

1968

Benevento District Court

R.G. 5021/12,

08/01/2013

Benevento District Court

R.G. 485/2015,

12/02/2015

Benevento District Court

R.G. 1064/2015,

12/03/2015

17/06/2022

27/07/2022