BIONDI v. ITALY

BIONDI v. ITALY (CtEDO, 2023)

Primă secțiune decizia nr. 39879/21 Pasquale BIONDI și Emanuele BIONDI împotriva Italiei și a altor două cereri (a se vedea tabelul anexat) Curtea Europeană a Drepturilor Omului (prima secțiune), care așezează la 23 martie 2023 în calitate de comitet compus din: Alena Poláčková , Președintele Gilberto Felici , Raffaele Sabato , judecători și Viktoriya Maradodina , grefierul adjunct al secțiunii interioare; Având în vedere cererile depuse mai sus la diferitele date indicate în tabelul adăugat, având în vedere declarațiile prezentate de guvernul contestat cere Curții să elimine cererile din lista cazurilor, după ce a deliberat, hotărăște după cum urmează: FACTE ȘI PROCEDIU Lista reclamanților este prezentată în tabelul adăugat. Reclamanții au fost reprezentați de Biondi Pasquale, un avocat care practică în Telese Terme. Părțile reclamanților în temeiul articolului 6 § 1 din Convenție și art. 1 din Protocolul nr. 1 privind neexecuția sau aplicarea întârziere a deciziilor interne au fost comunicate guvernului italian („Guvernul”). Având în vedere subiectul similar al cererilor, Curtea consideră oportun să le examineze în comun într-o singură hotărâre. Guvernul a informat Curtea că au propus să facă declarații unilaterale în vederea soluționării problemelor formulate de aceste plângeri. Guvernul a recunoscut neîndeplinirea sau întârziarea aplicării deciziilor interne, oferind reclamanților sumele detaliate în tabelul adăugat și invitat Curtea să scoată cererile din lista cazurilor în conformitate cu art. 37 § 1 litera (c) din Convenție. Sumele vor fi plătite în termen de trei luni de la data notificării hotărârii Curții. În cazul în care nu s-au plătit aceste sume în termenul de trei luni menționat anterior, guvernul s-a angajat să le plătească dobânzi simple, de la expirarea perioadei respective până la decontare, la o rată egală cu rata marginală de împrumut a Băncii Centrale Europene în timpul perioadei implicite plus trei puncte procentuale. Guvernul s-a angajat, de asemenea, să asigure executarea deciziilor interne examinate în cazurile în cauză (a se vedea tabelul adăugat) în aceeași perioadă de trei luni și să plătească orice costuri ale procedurii interne de punere în aplicare. Reclamanții au fost trimiși termenii declarațiilor unilaterale ale Guvernului cu câteva săptămâni înainte de data prezentei decizii. Curtea nu a primit un răspuns din partea reclamanților care acceptă termenii declarațiilor. Curtea observă că art. 37 § § § (c) îi permite să scoată un caz din lista sa dacă: „... din orice alt motiv stabilit de Curte, nu mai este justificat să continue examinarea cererii”. Astfel, aceasta poate elimina cererile în temeiul articolului 37 § 1 litera (c) pe baza unei declarații unilaterale de către un guvern contestat, chiar dacă reclamanții doresc să continue examinarea cazurilor (a se vedea, în special, Tahsin Acar c. Turcia) Hotărârea (obiecții preliminare) [GC], nr. 26307/95, §§ 77, CEDO 2003-VI). Curtea a stabilit o jurisprudență clară și extensă privind plângerile referitoare la neexecuția sau aplicarea întârziere a deciziilor interne (a se vedea, de exemplu, Ventorino c. Italia, nr. 357/07, 17 mai 2011, De Trana c. Italia, nr. 64215/01, 16 octombrie 2007, Nicola Silvestri c. Italia, nr. 16861/02, 9 iunie 2009, și Antonetto c. Italia, nr. 15918/89, 20 iulie 2000). Observarea admiterilor conținute în declarațiile guvernamentale, precum și cantitatea de compensare propusă – care este în concordanță cu sumele acordate în cazuri similare – Curtea consideră că nu mai este justificată continuarea examinării cererilor (art. 37 § § § c)). Având în vedere considerentele de mai sus, Curtea este convinsă că respectarea drepturilor omului, astfel cum este definită în Convenție și în Protocolurile sale, nu impune ca aceasta să continue examinarea cererilor (art. 37 § în amendă În sfârșit, Curtea subliniază că, în cazul în care Guvernul nu respectă termenii declarațiilor lor unilaterale, cererile pot fi restaurate pe listă în conformitate cu art. 37 § 2 din Convenție (a se vedea Josipović c. Serbia (dec.), nr. 18369/07, 4 martie 2008). Având în vedere cele de mai sus, este oportun să se scoată cazurile din listă. Din aceste motive, Curtea, în unanimitate, Decide să se alăture cererilor; ia act de termenii declarațiilor guvernului contestat și de modalitățile de asigurare a respectării întreprinderilor menționate în acest articol; decide să scoată cererile din lista sa de cazuri în conformitate cu art. 37 § litera (c) din Convenție. Adoptate în limba engleză și notificate în scris la 13 aprilie 2023. Viktoriya Maradudina Alena Poláčková Președintele Adjunct Registrul interimar APENDIX Lista cererilor care pun plângeri în temeiul articolului 6 § 1 din Convenție (neexercitare sau întârziere de aplicare a deciziilor interne) nr. Cerere nr. Data introducerii Numele reclamantului Anul nașterii Decizia interimar relevantă Data primirii declarației Guvernului Suport acordat pentru prejudicii morale per solicitant (în euro) [1] Sumele acordate pentru costurile și cheltuielile pe cerere (în euro) [2] 39879/21 05/08/2021 Pasquale BIONDI 1975 Emanuele BIONDI 1942 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2240/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2241/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2238/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2239/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2238/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2231/11, 27/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2268/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2269/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2264/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2266/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2667/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2265/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2619/11, 01/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3822/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3814/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3815/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2237/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2220/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2226/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2230/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2228/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2835/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2234/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2394/11, 15/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. necunoscut, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4325/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4025/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4024/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4313/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4317/11, 26/08/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4320/11, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4324/11, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4316/11, 02/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4315/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4328/11, 09/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4312/11, 22/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4332/11, 22/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4314/11, 06/06/2012 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4318/11, 06/06/2012 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2927/12, 28/12/2012 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5011/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5010/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5014/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5019/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5002/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5004/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4999/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5001/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1920/12, 08/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4994/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4970/12, 15/01/2013 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4969/11, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4971/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4974/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4978/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4979/12, 12/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4977/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4985/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4987/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4991/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4992/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4840/11, 08/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4839/11 - 5873/11, 08/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5641/11, 22/04/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4815/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4813/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4816/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4817/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5619/11 - 5875/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5627/11 - 6201/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5618/11 - 5874/11, 29/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5648/11, 20/09/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5649/11, 20/09/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4918/13, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4917/13, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4915/13, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4914/13, 05/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6190/11, 30/01/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5628/11, 31/03/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5631/11, 31/03/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5632/11, 31/03/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5643/11, 31/03/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2604/14, 30/05/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2609/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2688/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2611/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2777/14, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2682/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2683/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2803/15, 05/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2753/15, 10/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2838/15, 18/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2913/15, 18/06/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3976/15, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3975/15, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3978/15, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2766/16, 31/05/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2772/16, 31/05/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2770/16, 31/05/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2751/16, 01/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2750/16, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2816/16, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2803/16, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2778/16, 06/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2804/16, 06/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2784/16, 06/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2780/16, 06/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2818/16, 06/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2798/16, 07/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2812/16, 07/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2793/16, 07/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2765/16, 13/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 2749/16, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2809/16, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2779/16, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2795/16, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2796/16, 13/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2794/16, 14/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2771/16, 14/06/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2794/16, 14/06/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4046/16, 25/08/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4797/16, 07/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4790/16, 10/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4788/16, 10/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4789/16, 26/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 4786/16, 26/10/2016 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5931/16, 02/12/2016 Curtea de Apel a Naples R.G. 7145/13, 14/02/2017 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 38/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 31/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 11/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 14/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 18/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 21/18, 12/01/2018 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 24/18, 12/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 23/18, 20/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 28/18, 25/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 29/18, 25/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 19/18, 25/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 40/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 43/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 39/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2618/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 15/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 17/18, 26/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 41/2018, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 42/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4418/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 34/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 35/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 36/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 37/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 27/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 30/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 32/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 12/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 13/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 16/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 20/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 22/18, 30/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 474/18, 30/01/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 7148/13, 01/02/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 3622/14, 04/10/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 7147/13, 11/10/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 4408/14, 24/10/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 4411/14, 15/11/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 6691/13, 29/01/2019 Curtea de Apel a Naples R.G. 6120/13, 05/02/2019 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1502/20, 04/05/2020 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1506/20, 04/05/2020 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1504/20, 04/05/2020 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1503/20, 04/05/20 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1501/20, 04/05/20 Curtea de District a Benevento R.G. 1535/20, 07/05/20 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1527/20, 07/05/2020 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1523/20, 07/05/2020 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1543/20, 07/05/20 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1515/20, 07/05/2020 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1528/20, 08/05/20 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1536/20, 08/05/20 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1516/20, 08/05/20 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1524/20, 08/05/20 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1520/20, 08/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1510/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1517/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1505/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1518/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 150/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1534/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1522/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1530/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1514/20, 13/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 15/05/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 15/05/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1507/20, 15/05/20 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1521/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1525/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1537/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1529/20, 15/05/2020 Tribunalul de Apel Naples R.G. 925/14, 19/06/2020 18/11/2022 12,500 250 39890/21 02/08/2021 Tribunalul de District Pasquale BIONDI 1975 Emanuele BIONDI 1942 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2251/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2618/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2254/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2255/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2253/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2256/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2257/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2243/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2246/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2260/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2258/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2259/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2248/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2247/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2261/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2621/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2250/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2262/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2932/11, 01/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2252/11, 06/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3809/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3810/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3811/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3824/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3826/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 8281/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3825/11, 11/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2225/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2229/11, 14/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3816/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2233/11, 15/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3816/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4319/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4311/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4323/11, 05/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2263/11, 30/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4397/11, 08/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4691/11, 21/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4330/11, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4322/11, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4310/11, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3817/11, 19/07/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4568/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4980/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4984/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4982/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4988/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4986/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4989/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4990/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5012/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5013/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5016/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5020/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5022/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5023/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5017/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4981/12, 09/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4972/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4975/12, 15/12/2012 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4998/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5006/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5007/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5009/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5008/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4983/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5003/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4822/11, 08/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4823/11, 08/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4824/11, 27/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4844/11, 27/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4845/11, 27/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4821/11, 27/03/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5640/11, 22/04/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4843/11, 22/04/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4995/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4819/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4812/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4811/11, 13/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5622/11 - 5708/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5621/11 - 5706/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6433/11 - 6525/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5626/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5620/11 - 5991/11, 17/05/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5623/11, 10/06/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4820/11 - 6544/11, 10/06/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2245/11, 09/06/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4976/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4973/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4993/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4842/11, 03/10/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4334/11, 26/09/2011 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5638/11, 08/10/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2599/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2607/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2608/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2610/14, 03/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2779/11, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2778/14, 05/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2681/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2786/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2789/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2603/14, 09/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2773/14, 17/06/2014 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 3979/15, 25/08/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4304/15, 14/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4295/15, 14/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4208/15, 16/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4250/15, 16/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6140/16, 14/12/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6139/16, 15/12/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6137/16, 28/12/2016 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1922/17, 19/04/2017 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1921/17, 28/04/2017 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 2547/17, 22/05/2017 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5953/15, 29/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4251/15, 16/09/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6502/15, 29/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6504/15, 29/01/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6501/15, 20/04/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5950/15, 21/05/2018 Tribunalul de Apel Naples R.G. 205/14, 25/05/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 6499/15, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5958/15, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5945/15, 12/07/2018 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5948/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5952/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 804/14, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 5951/15, 12/07/2018 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 6503/15, 16/07/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 7547/13, 21/09/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 1242/14, 08/10/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 1254/14, 12/12/2018 Curtea de Apel de Napoli R.G. 6690/13, 13/12/2018 Tribunalul de district Benevento R.G. 1080/17, 17/12/2018 Curtea de apel de Napoli R.G. 6689/13, 29/04/2019 Curtea de district de Benevento R.G. 3471/17, 30/09/2019 Curtea de apel de Napoli R.G. 7110/13, 14/10/2019 Curtea de apel de Napoli R.G. 1255/14, 12/11/2019 Curtea de district de Benevento R.G. 3470/17, 12/12/2019 Curtea de apel de Napoli R.G. 7832/13, 18/12/2019 Curtea de district de Benevento R.G. 2119/17, 16/01/2020 18/11/2022 12,500 250 40228/21 29/07/2021 Pasquale BIONDI 1975 Emanuele BIONDI 1942 Benevento R.G. 2270/11, 30/06/2011 Benevento district Court R.G. 4327/11, 05/09/2011 Benevento district Court R.G. 4335/11, 05/09/2011 Benevento district Court R.G. 4331/11, 05/09/2011 Benevento district Court R.G. 5021/12, 08/01/2013 Benevento district Court R.G. 5018/12, 08/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5794/11, 06/06/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4997/12, 08/06/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 5034/13, 07/11/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 485/15, 12/02/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 483/15, 05/03/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 817/15, 09/03/2015 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 4996/12, 15/01/2013 Tribunalul de District Benevento R.G. 1060/11, 12/03/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1062/15, 12/03/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1064/15, 12/03/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 484/15, 18/03/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1063/15, 23/03/2015 Curtea de District Benevento R.G. 1061/15, 16/04/2015 18/11/2022 12,500 250 [1] Plus orice impozit care poate fi imputabil reclamanților. [2] Plus orice impozit care poate fi imputabil reclamanților.

FIRST SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 39879/21

Pasquale BIONDI and Emanuele BIONDI against Italy

and 2 other applications

(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 23 March 2023 as a Committee composed of:

Alena Poláčková

, President

,

Gilberto Felici,

Raffaele Sabato

, judges

,

and Viktoriya Maradudina,

Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having regard to the declarations submitted by the respondent Government requesting the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.

The applicants were represented by Biondi Pasquale, a lawyer practising in Telese Terme.

The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article

1 of Protocol No. 1 concerning the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions were communicated to the Italian Government (“the Government”).

THE LAW

Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

The Government informed the Court that they proposed to make unilateral declarations with a view to resolving the issues raised by these complaints. They further requested the Court to strike out the applications in accordance with Article

37 of the Convention.

The Government acknowledged the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions. They offered to pay the applicants the amounts detailed in the appended table and invited the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention. The amounts would be payable within three months from the date of notification of the Court’s decision. In the event of failure to pay these amounts within the above-mentioned three-month period, the Government undertook to pay simple interest on them, from the expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. The Government also undertook to ensure the enforcement of the domestic decisions under consideration in the cases concerned (see appended table) within the same three-month period, and to pay any costs of the domestic enforcement proceedings.

The applicants were sent the terms of the Government’s unilateral declarations several weeks before the date of this decision. The Court has not received a response from the applicants accepting the terms of the declarations.

The Court observes that Article

37 §

1

(c) enables it to strike a case out of its list if:

“... for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application”.

Thus, it may strike out applications under Article

37 §

1 (c) on the basis of a unilateral declaration by a respondent Government even if the applicants wish the examination of the cases to be continued (see, in particular, the

Tahsin Acar v.

Turkey

judgment (preliminary objections) [GC], no.

26307/95, §§

75

‑

77, ECHR 2003-VI).

The Court has established clear and extensive case-law concerning complaints relating to the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions (see, for example,

Ventorino v. Italy,

no. 357/07, 17 May 2011,

De Trana v. Italy,

no. 64215/01, 16 October 2007,

Nicola Silvestri v.

Italy,

no. 16861/02, 9 June 2009, and

Antonetto v. Italy,

no. 15918/89, 20

July 2000).

Noting the admissions contained in the Government’s declarations as well as the amount of compensation proposed – which is consistent with the amounts awarded in similar cases – the Court considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications (Article

37 §

1

(c)).

In the light of the above considerations, the Court is satisfied that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications (Article

37 §

1

in fine

).

Finally, the Court emphasises that, should the Government fail to comply with the terms of their unilateral declarations, the applications may be restored to the list in accordance with Article

37 §

2 of the Convention (see

Josipović v.

Serbia

(dec.), no.

18369/07, 4

March 2008).

In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides

to join the applications;

Takes note

of the terms of the respondent Government’s declarations and of the arrangements for ensuring compliance with the undertakings referred to therein;

Decides

to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article

37 §

1

(c) of the Convention.

Done in English and notified in writing on 13 April 2023.

Viktoriya Maradudina

Alena Poláčková

Acting Deputy Registrar

President

APPENDIX

List of applications raising complaints under Article

6 § 1 of the Convention

(non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions)

No.

Application no.

Date of introduction

Applicant’s name

Year of birth

Relevant domestic decision

Date of receipt of Government’s declaration

Amount awarded for non

‑

pecuniary damage

per applicant

(in euros)

[1]

Amount awarded for costs and expenses per application

(in euros)

[2]

39879/21

05/08/2021

Pasquale BIONDI

1975

Emanuele BIONDI

1942

Benevento District Court R.G. 2240/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2241/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2242/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2239/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2238/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2231/11, 27/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2268/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2269/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2264/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2266/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2667/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2265/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2619/11, 01/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3822/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3814/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3815/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2237/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2620/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2227/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2226/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2230/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2228/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2835/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2234/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2394/11, 15/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. unknown, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4325/11, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4025/11, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4024/11, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4313/11, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4317/11, 26/08/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4320/11, 02/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4324/11, 02/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4316/11, 02/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4315/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4328/11, 09/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4312/11, 22/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4332/11, 22/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4314/11, 06/06/2012

Benevento District Court R.G. 4318/11, 06/06/2012

Benevento District Court R.G. 2927/12, 28/12/2012

Benevento District Court R.G. 5011/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5010/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5014/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5019/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5002/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5004/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4999/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5001/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 1920/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4994/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4970/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4969/11, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4971/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4974/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4978/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4979/12, 12/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4977/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4985/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4987/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4991/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4992/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4840/11, 08/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4839/11 - 5873/11, 08/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5641/11, 22/04/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4815/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4813/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4816/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4817/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5619/11 - 5875/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5627/11 - 6201/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5618/11 - 5874/11, 29/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5648/11, 20/09/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5649/11, 20/09/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4918/13, 05/11/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4917/13, 05/11/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4915/13, 05/11/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4914/13, 05/11/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 6190/11, 30/01/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 5628/11, 31/03/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 5631/11, 31/03/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 5632/11, 31/03/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 5643/11, 31/03/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2604/14, 30/05/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2609/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2688/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2611/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2777/14, 05/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2682/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2683/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2803/15, 05/06/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 2753/15, 10/06/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 2838/15, 18/06/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 2913/15, 18/06/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 3976/15, 25/08/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 3975/15, 25/08/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 3978/15, 25/08/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 2766/16, 31/05/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2772/16, 31/05/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2770/16, 31/05/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2751/16, 01/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2750/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2816/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2813/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2768/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2778/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2804/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2784/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2780/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2818/16, 06/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2798/16, 07/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2812/16, 07/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2793/16, 07/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2765/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2749/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2809/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2779/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2795/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2796/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2781/16, 13/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2769/16, 14/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2771/16, 14/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 2794/16, 14/06/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4046/16, 25/08/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4797/16, 07/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4790/16, 10/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4788/16, 10/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4785/16, 10/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4789/16, 26/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 4786/16, 26/10/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 5931/16, 02/12/2016

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7145/13,

14/02/2017

Benevento District Court R.G. 38/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 31/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 11/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 14/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 18/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 21/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 24/18,

12/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 23/18,

20/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 28/18,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 29/18,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 19/18,

25/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 40/18,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 43/18,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 39/18,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 2618/18, 26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 15/18,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 17/18,

26/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 41/2018, 30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 42/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 4418/18, 30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 34/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 35/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 36/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 37/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 27/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 30/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 32/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 12/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 13/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 16/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 20/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 22/18,

30/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 474/18,

30/01/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7148/13,

01/02/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 3622/14,

04/10/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7147/13,

11/10/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 4408/14,

24/10/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 4411/14,

15/11/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 6691/13,

29/01/2019

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 6120/13,

05/02/2019

Benevento District Court R.G. 1502/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1506/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1508/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1504/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1503/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1501/20, 04/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1535/20, 07/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1527/20, 07/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1523/20, 07/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1543/20, 07/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1515/20, 07/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1528/20, 08/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1536/20, 08/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1516/20, 08/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1524/20, 08/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1520/20, 08/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1510/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1517/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1526/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1505/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1518/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1500/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1534/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1522/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1530/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1514/20, 13/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1533/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1509/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1513/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1507/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1521/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1525/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1537/20, 15/05/2020

Benevento District Court R.G. 1529/20, 15/05/2020

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 925/14,

19/06/2020

18/11/2022

12,500

250

39890/21

02/08/2021

Pasquale BIONDI

1975

Emanuele BIONDI

1942

Benevento District Court R.G. 2251/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2618/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2254/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2255/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2253/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2256/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2257/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2243/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2246/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2260/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2258/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2259/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2248/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2247/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2261/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2621/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2250/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2262/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2932/11, 01/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2252/11, 06/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3809/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3810/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3811/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3821/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3824/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3826/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 8281/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3825/11, 11/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2225/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2229/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2232/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2236/11, 14/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2233/11, 15/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3816/11, 19/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4319/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4311/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4323/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 2263/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4397/11, 08/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4691/11, 21/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4330/11, 26/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4322/11, 26/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4310/11, 26/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 3817/11, 19/07/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4568/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4980/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4984/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4982/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4988/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4986/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4989/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4990/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5012/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5013/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5016/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5020/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5022/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5023/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5017/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4981/12, 09/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4972/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4975/12, 15/12/2012

Benevento District Court R.G. 4998/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5006/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5007/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5009/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5008/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4983/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5003/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4822/11, 08/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4823/11, 08/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4824/11, 27/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4844/11, 27/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4845/11, 27/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4821/11, 27/03/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5640/11, 22/04/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4843/11, 22/04/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4995/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4819/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4812/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4811/11, 13/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5622/11 - 5708/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5621/11 - 5706/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 6433/11 - 6525/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5626/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5620/11 - 5991/11, 17/05/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5623/11, 10/06/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4820/11 - 6544/11, 10/06/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 2245/11, 09/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4976/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4973/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4993/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4842/11, 03/10/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4334/11, 26/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 5638/11, 08/10/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 2599/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2607/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2608/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2610/14, 03/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2779/11, 05/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2778/14, 05/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2681/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2786/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2789/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2603/14, 09/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 2773/14, 17/06/2014

Benevento District Court R.G. 3979/15, 25/08/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 4304/15, 14/09/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 4295/15, 14/09/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 4208/15, 16/09/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 4250/15, 16/09/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 6140/16, 14/12/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 6139/16, 15/12/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 6137/16, 28/12/2016

Benevento District Court R.G. 1922/17, 19/04/2017

Benevento District Court R.G. 1921/17, 28/04/2017

Benevento District Court R.G. 2547/17, 22/05/2017

Benevento District Court R.G. 5953/15, 29/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 4251/15, 16/09/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 6502/15, 29/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 6504/15, 29/01/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 6501/15, 20/04/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5950/15, 21/05/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 205/14,

25/05/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 6499/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5958/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5945/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5948/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5952/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 804/14,

12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 5951/15, 12/07/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 6503/15, 16/07/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7547/13,

21/09/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 1242/14,

08/10/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 1254/14,

12/12/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 6690/13,

13/12/2018

Benevento District Court R.G. 1080/17, 17/12/2018

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 6689/13,

29/04/2019

Benevento District Court R.G. 3471/17, 30/09/2019

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7110/13,

14/10/2019

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 1255/14,

12/11/2019

Benevento District Court R.G. 3470/17, 12/12/2019

Naples Court of Appeal R.G. 7832/13,

18/12/2019

Benevento District Court R.G. 2119/17, 16/01/2020

18/11/2022

12,500

250

40228/21

29/07/2021

Pasquale BIONDI

1975

Emanuele BIONDI

1942

Benevento District Court R.G. 2270/11, 30/06/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4327/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4335/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 4331/11, 05/09/2011

Benevento District Court R.G. 5021/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5018/12, 08/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5794/11, 06/06/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 4997/12, 08/06/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 5034/13, 07/11/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 485/15,

12/02/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 483/15,

05/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 817/15,

09/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 4996/12, 15/01/2013

Benevento District Court R.G. 1060/11, 12/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 1062/15, 12/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 1064/15, 12/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 484/15,

18/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 1063/15, 23/03/2015

Benevento District Court R.G. 1061/15, 16/04/2015

18/11/2022

12,500

250

[1]

Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.

[2]

Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants.