KANALYUK AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA

KANALYUK AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA (CtEDO, 2025)

A doua secțiune DECIZIE nr. 44466/15 Maryna Yuriyivna KANALYUK împotriva Rusiei și alte 27 de cereri (a se vedea tabelul anexat) Curtea Europeană a Drepturilor Omului (a patra secțiune), care stă la 20 noiembrie 2025 în calitate de comitet compus din: Faris Vehabović , Președintele Lorraine Schembri Orland , Anne Louise Bormann , judecători și Viktoriya Maradudina , grefier adjunct al secțiunii interioare , Având în vedere cererile depuse mai sus la diferitele date indicate în tabelul adăugat, după deliberare, hotărăște după cum urmează: FACTE ȘI PROCEDIU Lista reclamanților este prezentată în apendice. Aceste cereri provin din conflictul dintre Ucraina și Federația Rusă după ocuparea și anexarea Crimeei de către Rusia în 2014. Diferite plângeri ale reclamanților în temeiul Convenției au fost comunicate guvernului rus („Guvernului”), care nu și-au prezentat observațiile. Reclamanții au fost obligați să își prezinte observațiile, împreună cu orice reclamație pentru satisfacție echitabilă (a se vedea detaliile din apendice). În cazul în care reclamanții nu și-au prezentat observațiile, prin scrisorile trimise prin intermediul serviciului de comunicare electronică (eComms) al Curții și/sau prin post înregistrat, acestea au fost notificate că perioada permisă pentru prezentarea observațiilor lor a expirat și că nu au fost solicitate prelungirea termenului (a se vedea tabelul adăugat pentru detalii suplimentare). (a) din Convenție, care prevede că Curtea poate elimina o cerere din lista cazurilor în care circumstanțele conduc la concluzia că reclamantul nu intenționează să urmeze cererea. Cu toate acestea, nu a fost primit niciun răspuns. Având în vedere comportamentul procedural similar al reclamanților, Curtea consideră oportun să le examineze în comun într-o decizie unică. Având în vedere cele de mai sus și în absența unor circumstanțe speciale privind respectarea drepturilor garantate de Convenția și de protocolele sale, Curtea, în conformitate cu articolul (a) din Convenție, consideră că nu mai este justificat să continue examinarea cererilor. În consecință, cazurile ar trebui să fie excluse din listă. Curtea reiterează că, în conformitate cu art. 37 § 2 din Convenție, poate decide să restabilească o cerere la lista cazurilor, dacă consideră că circumstanțele justifică acest curs. Din aceste motive, Curtea, în unanimitate, Decide să se alăture cererilor; hotărăște să scoată cererile din lista de cazuri. Adoptate în limba engleză și notificate în scris la 11 decembrie 2025. Viktoriya Maradudina Faris Vehabović Președintele adjunct al grefierului interimar APENDIX Lista cererilor nr. Cerere nr. Locată la Anul de naștere/registrare al reclamantului Locația de reședință Naționalitate Reprezentată de principalele plângeri formulate Data scrisorii Curții care invită reclamanții să prezinte observațiile lor Data scrisorii ultimei Curții 444666/15 03/09/2015 Maryna Yuriyivna KANALYUK 1978 Odesa Ucrainean Art. 8 (1) — Acasă Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 22/02/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 05/02/2024 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 50688/15 28/09/2015 Vitaliy Dmytrovych POCHUZHEVSKYY 1972 Odesa Ucrainean Bogdan Ivanovych KOPTSYUKH Art. 8 (1) — Acasă Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 22/02/2023 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 05/02/2024 (de la postul înregistrat — restituit fără livrări) 50821/15 01/10/2015 Denys Igorovych ODRASHKA 1977 Odesa Ucrainean Art. 8 (1) — Acasă Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 22/02/2023 (de la eComms — nu descărcat) 05/02/2024 (de la postul înregistrat — remis fără livrări) 50839/15 03/10/2015 Sergiy Mykolayovych KARPENKO 1971 Odesa Ukrainian Anatoliy Fedorovych LYSENKO Art. 8 (1) — Home Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 23/03/2023 (de către eComms — descărcat la 27/03/223) 05/02/2024 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 31559/16 19/05/2016 Roman Mykhaylovych OTKYDACH 1978 Mykolayiv Ukrainian Art. 8 (1) — Home Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 15/02/2024 (prin post înregistrat — restituit neînnoit) 01/10/2024 (prin post înregistrat — restituit neînnoit) 52652/16 26/08/2016 Maksym Viktorovych KIRIAKIDI 1975 Odesa Ucrainean Art. 8 (1) — Acasă Art. 14 — Interzicerea discriminării 22/02/2023 (de către eComms — descărcat la 22/02/223) 05/02/2024 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 7956/16 01/12/2016 Anatoliy Nikolayevich ZOTOV 1954 Yalta Rusă Sergey Yevgenyevich TARANENKO 1954 Yalta rusă Andrey Viktorovich TIMCHUK Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Controlul utilizării proprietăților 05/07/2024 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 31/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 2410/17 19/12/2016 UNIUNEA NAȚIONALĂ A UKRAINE 1991 Bila Tserkva Ucrainean Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 24/11/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 05/04/20224 (prin post înregistrat — livrat la 28/05/2024) 67094/17 22/08/2017 OOO ALUPKA REZORT 2004 Yalta Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 04/12/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 31/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 10. 18084/18 02/04/2018 Nataliya Viktorivna KOMASHKO 1981 Sevastopol Ucrainean Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Controlul utilizării proprietăților 05/07/2024 (prin eComms — descărcat la 05/07/2024) 31/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 11. 40312/18 01/08/2018 GARAGE CONSTRUCTION YOPERATIVE YUG 2014 Yalta Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 04/12/2023 (de eComms — descărcat la 12/04/2024) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — descărcat la 07/02/202) 12. 43931/18 07/09/2018 Igor Yurievich PETRENKO 1987 Yalta Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 04/12/2023 (prin eComms — descărcat la 04/12/2023) 30/01/2025 (prin eComms — descărcat la 30/01/202) 13. 49973/18 12/10/2018 OOO SEVASTOPOL 2007 Sebastopol rus Aleksandr Olegovich FILONOV Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 06/12/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 14. 59880/18 15/12/2018 Anzhela Vladimovna VEGERA 1977 Sebastopol Rusă Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 20/11/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 15. 59883/18 17/12/2018 Vyacheslav Yurievich VEGERA 1973 Sebastopol Rusă Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 20/11/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (prin eComms — nu este descărcat) 16. 3346/19 24/12/2018 OOO OBYEDINENIYE TRANS-KONTINENTAL+ 2015 Simferopol Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 06/12/2023 (de eComms — nu este descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu este descărcat) 17. 13745/19 05/03/2019 Yelena Arkadyevna KABAK 1971 Yalta, Crimea Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 01/12/2023 (de către eComms — descărcat la 16/12/2023) 30/01/2025 (de către eComms — descărcat la 13/02/225) 18. 20449/19 10/04/2019 Sergey Nikolayevich MARDOVTSEV 1988 Noyabrsk Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 20/11/2023 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 19. 28097/19 15/05/2019 Tatyana Alekseyevna MIKHAYLOVA 1963 Novosibirsk Rusă Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivare proprietate/interes public 20/11/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 20. 60372/19 07/11/2019 Leonid Pavlovich BEREZHNY 1939 Alushta rusă Andrey Viktorovich LOGINOV Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivare proprietate/interes public 24/11/2023 (de eComms — descărcat pe 24/11/2023) 05/04/2024 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 21. 6047/20/10/2020 OOO MKP AGROSTROY Dzhankoy Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 06/12/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 22. 22374/20 03/06/2020 BAKHCHYSARAI DISTRICT CONSUMER ASSOCIATION Bakhchisaray Russian Yekaterina Borisovna Belova Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 06/12/2023 (de eComms — descărcat pe 24/01/2024) 30/01/2025 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 23. 34345/20 13/06/2020 AGROFIRMA CHERVONYY ZHOVTEN, KSP 1996 Kyiv Ucrainean Andrey Nikolayevich TARASEVICH Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 27/11/2023 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 11/04/2024 (de către postul înregistrat — returnat neentregat) 24. 35438/20 07/08/20 AGROFIRMA CHERVONYY ZHOVTEN, KSP 1996 Kyiv Ucrainean Andrey Nikolayevich TARASEVICH Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 27/11/2023 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 11/04/2024 (de către postul înregistrat — returnat neentregat) 25. 11481/21 04/03/2021 BAKHCHYSARAI DISTRICT CONSUMER ASSOCIATION Bakhchisaray Russian Yekaterina Borisovna Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 06/12/2023 (de către eComms — descărcat pe 18/10/204) 30/01/2025 (prin eComms — nu descărcat) 26. 31420/21 20/05/2021 Yelena Vladimirovna LEBEDEVA 1982 Sevastopol Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 20/11/2023 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de eComms — nu descărcat) 27. 6383/22 04/08/2021 Yelena Vladimirovna LEBEDEVA 1982 Sevastopol Russian Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Proprietate de privare/interes public 20/11/2023 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 30/01/2025 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 28. 175110/22 10/03/2022 AO RENTAL ENTERPRISE SIMFEROPOL PRODUCTION-COMMERCIAL FIRM "PHOTON" 2007 Simferopol rusesc David Toniyevich KARAMANUKYAN Prot. 1 Art. 1 — proprietate de privare/interes public 05/07/2024 (de către eComms — nu descărcat) 31/01/2025 (de către eComms — nu descărcat)

FOURTH SECTION

DECISION

Application no. 44466/15

Maryna Yuriyivna KANALYUK against Russia

and 27 other applications

(see appended table)

The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting on 20

November 2025 as a Committee composed of:

Faris Vehabović

, President

,

Lorraine Schembri Orland,

Anne Louise Bormann

, judges

,

and Viktoriya Maradudina,

Acting Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

FACTS AND PROCEDURE

The list of the applicants is set out in the appendix.

These applications originated from the conflict between Ukraine and the Russian Federation after the occupation and annexation of Crimea by Russia in 2014.

The applicants’ various complaints under the Convention were communicated to the Russian Government (“the Government”), who did not submit their observations. The applicants were required to submit their observations, together with any claims for just satisfaction (see details in the appendix).

When the applicants had failed to submit their observations, by letters sent via the Court’s Electronic Communication Service (eComms) and/or by registered post, they were notified that the period allowed for submission of their observations had expired and that no extension of time had been requested (see appended table for further details).

The applicants’ attention was drawn to Article

37

§

1

(a) of the Convention, which provides that the Court may strike an application out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to the conclusion that the applicant does not intend to pursue the application. However, no response has been received.

THE LAW

Having regard to the similar procedural conduct of the applicants, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.

In the light of the foregoing, and in the absence of any special circumstances regarding respect for the rights guaranteed by the Convention and the Protocols thereto, the Court, in accordance with Article

37

§

1

(a) of the Convention, considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications.

Accordingly, the cases should be struck out of the list.

The Court reiterates that under Article

37 §

2 of the Convention it may decide to restore an application to its list of cases if it considers that the circumstances justify such a course.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Decides

to join the applications;

Decides

to strike the applications out of its list of cases.

Done in English and notified in writing on 11

December 2025.

Viktoriya Maradudina

Faris Vehabović

Acting Deputy Registrar

President

APPENDIX

List of applications

No.

Application no.

Lodged on

Applicant

Year of birth/registration

Place of residence

Nationality

Represented by

Main complaints raised

Date of the Court’s letter inviting the applicants to submit their observations

Date of the last Court’s letter

1.

44466/15

03/09/2015

Maryna Yuriyivna KANALYUK

1978

Odesa

Ukrainian

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

22/02/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

05/02/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

2.

50688/15

28/09/2015

Vitaliy Dmytrovych POCHUZHEVSKYY

1972

Odesa

Ukrainian

Bogdan Ivanovych KOPTSYUKH

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

22/02/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

05/02/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

3.

50821/15

01/10/2015

Denys Igorovych ODRASHKA

1977

Odesa

Ukrainian

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

22/02/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

05/02/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

4.

50839/15

03/10/2015

Sergiy Mykolayovych KARPENKO

1971

Odesa

Ukrainian

Anatoliy Fedorovych LYSENKO

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

23/03/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 27/03/2023)

05/02/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

5.

31559/16

19/05/2016

Roman Mykhaylovych OTKYDACH

1978

Mykolayiv

Ukrainian

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

15/02/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

01/10/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

6.

52652/16

26/08/2016

Maksym Viktorovych KIRIAKIDI

1975

Odesa

Ukrainian

Art. 8 (1) — Home

Art. 14 — Prohibition of discrimination

22/02/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 22/02/2023)

05/02/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

7.

79566/16

01/12/2016

Anatoliy Nikolayevich ZOTOV

1954

Yalta

Russian

Sergey Yevgenyevich TARANENKO

1954

Yalta

Russian

Andrey Viktorovich TIMCHUK

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Control of use of property

05/07/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

31/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

8.

2410/17

19/12/2016

NATIONAL WRITERS’ UNION OF UKRAINE

1991

Bila Tserkva

Ukrainian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

24/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

05/04/2024

(by registered post — delivered on 28/05/2024)

9.

67094/17

22/08/2017

OOO ALUPKA REZORT

2004

Yalta

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

04/12/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

31/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

10.

18084/18

02/04/2018

Nataliya Viktorivna KOMASHKO

1981

Sevastopol

Ukrainian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Control of use of property

05/07/2024

(by eComms — downloaded on 05/07/2024)

31/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

11.

40312/18

01/08/2018

GARAGE CONSTRUCTION COOPERATIVE YUG

2014

Yalta

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

04/12/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 12/04/2024)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — downloaded on 07/02/2025)

12.

43931/18

07/09/2018

Igor Yuryevich PETRENKO

1987

Yalta

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

04/12/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 04/12/2023)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — downloaded on 30/01/2025)

13.

49973/18

12/10/2018

OOO SEVASTOPOL

2007

Sevastopol

Russian

Aleksandr Olegovich FILONOV

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

06/12/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

14.

59880/18

15/12/2018

Anzhela Vladimirovna VEGERA

1977

Sevastopol

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

15.

59883/18

17/12/2018

Vyacheslav Yuryevich VEGERA

1973

Sevastopol

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

16.

3346/19

24/12/2018

OOO OBYEDINENIYE TRANS-KONTINENTAL+

2015

Simferopol

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

06/12/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

17.

13745/19

05/03/2019

Yelena Arkadyevna KABAK

1971

Yalta, Crimea

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

01/12/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 16/12/2023)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — downloaded on 13/02/2025)

18.

20449/19

10/04/2019

Sergey Nikolayevich MARDOVTSEV

1988

Noyabrsk

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

19.

28097/19

15/05/2019

Tatyana Alekseyevna MIKHAYLOVA

1963

Novosibirsk

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

20.

60372/19

07/11/2019

Leonid Pavlovich BEREZHNYY

1939

Alushta

Russian

Andrey Viktorovich LOGINOV

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

24/11/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 24/11/2023)

05/04/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

21.

6047/20

10/01/2020

OOO MKP AGROSTROY

Dzhankoy

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

06/12/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

22.

22374/20

03/06/2020

BAKHCHYSARAI DISTRICT CONSUMER ASSOCIATION

Bakhchisaray

Russian

Yekaterina Borisovna BELOVA

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

06/12/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 24/01/2024)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

23.

34345/20

13/06/2020

AGROFIRMA CHERVONYY ZHOVTEN, KSP

1996

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Andrey Nikolayevich TARASEVICH

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

27/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

11/04/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

24.

35438/20

07/08/2020

AGROFIRMA CHERVONYY ZHOVTEN, KSP

1996

Kyiv

Ukrainian

Andrey Nikolayevich TARASEVICH

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

27/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

11/04/2024

(by registered post — returned undelivered)

25.

11481/21

04/03/2021

BAKHCHYSARAI DISTRICT CONSUMER ASSOCIATION

Bakhchisaray

Russian

Yekaterina Borisovna BELOVA

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

06/12/2023

(by eComms — downloaded on 18/10/2024)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

26.

31420/21

20/05/2021

Yelena Vladimirovna LEBEDEVA

1982

Sevastopol

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

27.

6383/22

04/08/2021

Yelena Vladimirovna LEBEDEVA

1982

Sevastopol

Russian

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

20/11/2023

(by eComms — not downloaded)

30/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)

28.

17510/22

10/03/2022

AO RENTAL ENTERPRISE SIMFEROPOL PRODUCTION-COMMERCIAL FIRM "PHOTON"

2007

Simferopol

Russian

David Toniyevich KARAMANUKYAN

Prot. 1 Art. 1 — Deprivation property/public interest

05/07/2024

(by eComms — not downloaded)

31/01/2025

(by eComms — not downloaded)