ANDREY RYLKOV FOUNDATION FOR THE PROTECTION OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL JUSTICE v. RUSSIA and 82 other applications
- Instanță
- CtEDO
- Concluzie
- Communicated
ANDREY RYLKOV FOUNDATION FOR THE PROTECTION OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL JUSTICE v. RUSSIA and 82 other applications (CtEDO, 2023)
Publicat la 6 martie 2023 SECȚIUNEA TERZĂ Cererea nr. 37949/18 ANDREY RYLKOV FOUNDATION împotriva Rusiei și alte 82 de cereri (a se vedea lista anexată) comunicată la 13 februarie 2023 OBIECTUL CAUZEI Cerințele se referă la amendamentele din legislația rusă din 2015 care au instituit o nouă categorie de „organizații nedorite” și au impus sancțiuni administrative și penale pentru implicarea în activitățile lor. Reclamanții includ trei organizații care au fost desemnate „nedorite” – Free Russia Foundation (USA), Congresul Mondial Ucrainean (Ucraina) și Asociația Școlilor de Studii Politice a Consiliului Europei (Franța) – și un număr mare de solicitanți individuali, resortisanți ruși, care au fost condamnați pentru participarea la activități organizate de „organizările nedorite” sau pentru utilizarea simbolurilor lor. Întrebări adresate părților În ceea ce privește organizațiile solicitante în cererile nr. 26953/21, 44688/21 și 53201/22, s-a constatat o încălcare a articolelor 10 și 11 din Convenție din cauza desemnării lor ca „organizații neîncredințabile”? În ceea ce privește ceilalți solicitanți, a existat o încălcare a articolelor 10 și 11 din Convenție din cauza condamnării acestora pentru participarea la activitățile „organizațiilor nedorite”? Apendice Listă de cereri Număr de cerere Denumire de caz Lodged on Solicitant An of Nasce of Residence Reprezentat de 37949/18* Andrey Rylkov Foundation c. Russia 17/07/2018 FOND SODEYSTVIYA ZASHCHITE ZDOROVYA I SOSTIALNOY SPRAVEDLIVOSTI ANDREYA RYLKOVA 2009 Moscova Maksim Vladimirovich OLENICHEV 40948/18* Malysheva c. Rusia 14/08/2018 Olga Valentinovna MALYSHEVA 1956 Kaliningrad Mariya Vladimirovna BONTSLER 4109/18* Grigoriev v. Rusia 04/08/2018 Yakov Aleksandrovich GRIGORYEV 1984 Svetlogorsk Mariya Vladimovna BONTSLER 43290/18* Kravchenko v. Rusia 01/09/2018 Anton Petrovich KRAVCHENKO 1985 Tsyvilsk Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 45567/18* Shevchenko v. Rusia 06/09/2018 Anastasiya Nukzariyevna SHEVCHENKO 1979 Rostov na Donu Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 45990/18* Savvin v. Rusia 13/09/2018 Oleg Sergeyevich SAVVIN 1988 Kaliningrad Mariya Vladimirovna BONTSLER 55960/18* Zhilkin v. Rusia 15/11/2018 Vladimir Vladimirovikovich ZHILKIN 1974 Tambov Dmitriy Eduardovich PYATAKHIN 4438/19* Vodyanitskiy c. Rusia 31/12/2018 Oleg Stanislavovich VODYANITSKIY 1967 Kaliningrad Mariya Vladimirovna BONTSLER 8570/19* Zaprudina c. Rusia 31/01/2019 Marina Yevgenyevna ZAPRUDINA 1981 Krasnodar 10. 10068/19* Semenov c. Rusia 08/02/2019 Dmitriy Anatolievich SEMENOV 1989 Tsivilsk Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 11. 111702/19* Shevchenko c. Rusia 21/02/2019 Anastasiya Nukzariyevna SHEVCHENKO 1979 Rostov na Donu Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 12. 12170/19* Klimov v. Rusia 25/02/2019 Maksim Yevgenyevich KLIMOV 1992 Krasnaya Yaruga Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 13. 13527/19* Mikhalchuk v. Rusia 14/02/2019 Anton Sergeyevich MIKHALCHUK 1990 Bogandinskiy Maksim Vladimirovich OLENICHEV 14. 16258/19* Kladovoy v. Rusia 11/03/2019 Nikolay Igorevich KLADOVOY 1965 Rostov-na-Donu 15. 18119/19* Mikhalchuk v. Rusia 16/03/2019 Anton Sergeyevich MIKHALCHUK 1990 Bogandinskiy Maksim Vladimovich OLENICHEV 16. 18324/19* Zaytsev v. Rusia 21/03/2019 Roman Olegovich ZAYTSEV 1989 Volgograd Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 17. 1926/19* Malyavin v. Rusia 26/03/2019 Leonid Vladimovich MALYAVIN 1958 Krasnodar Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 18. 24019/19* Ibragimov v. Rusia 19/04/2019 Denis Irekovich IBRAGIMOV 1996 Chelyabinsk Alena Sergeyevna BORISOVA 19. 25441/19 Vernikov v. Rusia 30/04/2019 Maksim Borisovich VERNIKOV 1992 Yekaterinburg Roman Yevgenyevich KACHANOV 20. 28922/19* Yegorov v. Rusia 18/05/2019 Dmitriy Aleksandrovich YEGOROV 1995 Kazan Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 21. 29477/19* Menshenina v. Rusia 17/05/2019 Yelena Aleksandrovna MENSHENINA 1966 Rostov-na-Donu Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 22. 31123/19+* Olga Zenina v. Rusia 21/05/2019 Olga Alekseyevna ZENINA 1952 Rostov-na-Donu Irina Aleksandrovna YATSENKO 23. 33187/19+* Irina Zenina v. Rusia 04/06/2019 Irina Alekseyevna ZENINA 1952 Rostov-na-Donu Irina Aleksandrovna YATSENKO 24. 35211/19* Klimov v. Rusia 28/06/2019 Maksim Yevgenyevich KLIMOV 1992 1992 Krasnaya Yaruga 25. 39715/19* Safronov v. Rusia 08/07/2019 Aleksandr Nikolayevich SAFRONOV 1987 Yeysk 26. 47641/19* Antonova v. Rusia 19/08/2019 Yana Gennadyevna ANTONOVA 1979 Krasnodar Alena Sergheyevna BORISOVA 27. 48765/19* Zaytsev v. Rusia 16/09/2019 Roman Olegovich ZAYTSEV 1989 Volgograd 28. 49203/19* Vernikov v. Rusia 26/08/2019 Maksim Borisovich VERNIKOV 1992 Yekaterinburg 1992 Roman Yevgenyevich KACHANOV 29. 49358/19* Pryanishnikov c. Rusia 16/09/2019 Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 1976 Tomsk Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 30. 55326/19* Yegorov c. Rusia 14/10/2019 Dmitriy Aleksandrovich YEGOROV 1995 Kazan Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 31. 62516/19 Savelyev c. Rusia 19/11/2019 Aleksandr Valerevich SAVELYEV 1996 Nekrasovskaya 32. 5907/20* Malyavin v. Rusia 14/01/202020 Leonid Vladimirovich MALYAVIN 1958 Krasnodar Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 33. 8940/20* Kiforuk c. Rusia 1/02/2020 Nikita Yevgenyevich KIFORUK 1991 Tyumen Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 34. 12215/20* Yarotskiy c. Rusia 19/02/2020 Andrey Alekseyevich YAROTSKIY 1991 Vladivostok Ivan Ivanovich KULIKOV 35. 13034/20* Ravilova c. Rusia 17/02/2020 Gulnaz Ilgizovna RAVILOVA 1999 Kazankovich Elza Rinatovna NISANBEKOVA 36. 14667/20* Grekov v. Rusia 09/03/2020 Yevgeniy Viktorovich GREKOV 1967 Krasnodar Aleksey Nikolayevich LAPTEV 37. 14731/20* Shaposhnikov v. Rusia 07/03/2020 Yuryevich SHAPOSHNIKOV 1987 Nizhniy Novgorod 38. 15444/20* Muraktayeva v. Rusia 07/03/2020 Irina Vyacheslavovna MURAKHTAYEVA 1973-2020 Nizhniy Novgorod Heir: Aleksey Viktorovich MURRAKHTAYEV 1973 Aleksey Aleksandrovich MATASOV 39. 17171/20* Karavayev v. Rusia 06/03/2020 Aleksandr Yevgenyevich KARAVAYEV 1985 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksandr Dmitriyevich PEREDRUK 40. 27716/20* Aleksa v. Rusia 03/04/2020 Nina Andreyevna ALEKSA 1984 Moscova Georgie Eduardovich TEVOSOV 41: 31967/20* North Caucase Mediu Watch și Rudomakha v. Rusia 15/06/2020 EKOLOGICHES KAYA VAKHTA PO SEVERNO KAVKAZU 2004 Maykop Andrey Vladimirovich RUDOMAKHA 1964 Maykop Vladimirovich OLENICHEV 42. 34063/20 Makarov v. Rusia 04/08/2020 Gennadiy Gennadyevich MAKAROV 1983 Yelets Konstantin Ilyich TEREKHOV 43. 34206/20+* North Caucas Mediu Watch v. Rusia 13/07/2020 EKOLOGICHES KAYA VAKHTA PO SEVERNOMU KAVAZU 2004 Maykop Maksim Vladimovich OLENICHEV 44. 34258/20+* Tinerii Jurnalisti Altay v. Rusia 15/06/2020 AKOO MOLODYYE ZHURNALISTY ALTAYA 1996 Barnaul Yelena Yurievna PERSHAKOVA 45. 43091/20* Fedotova c. Rusia 27/08/2020 Yuliya Yevgenyevna FEDOTOVA 1992 Yekaterinburg Aleksey Viktorovich AVANESYAN 46. 26953/21 Iosilevich c. Rusia 16/12/2020 Mikhail Aleksandrovich IOSILEVICH 1976 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksey Aleksandrovich MATASOV 47. 31236/21+* Free Russia Foundation v. Russia 24/05/2021 FREE RUSIA FOUNDATION 2014 Alexandria 48. 32026/21+* Usmanova c. Rusia 27/05/2021 Tatyana Yurievna USMANOVA 1983 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 49. 32206/21+* Molodykh c. Rusia 06/06/2021 Aleksey Nikolayevich MOLODEVYKH 1970 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 50. 322020/21+* Rakhilin c. Rusia 09/06/2021 Konstantin Valentinovich RAKHILIN 1966 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 51. 33360/21* Lebedev v. Rusia 11/06/2021 Maksim Aleksandrovich LEBEDEV 1997 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksandrovich MATASOV 52. 33822/21+* Shaposhnikov v. Rusia 04/06/2021 Yuryevich SHAPOSHNIKOV 1987 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksey Alekseievch VETOSHKIN 53. 36590/21+* Daryin v. Rusia 24/06/2021 Aleksey Nikolayevich DAryIN 1989 Melkenkienkien Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 54. 36590/21+* Sokolov v. Rusia 08/07/2021 Sergey Yurievich SOKOLOV 1965 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 55. 37040/21+* Udachina v. Rusia 06/07/2021 Darya Andreyevna UDACHINA 2001 Vladivostok Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO 56. 37244/21+* Olevinskiy v. Rusia 08/07/2021 Timur Vladimovich OLEVSKIY 1976 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISNIKOVOV 57. 37320/21+* Marchenko c. Rusia 08/07/2021 Vadim Yanovich MARCHENKO 1971 Moscova 58. 37773/21+* Kravchuk c. Rusia 08/07/2021 Olga Vladimirovna KRAVCHUK 1975 Moscova 59. 41198/21* Kruglyakov c. Rusia 02/08/2021 Vladimir Mikhaylovich KRUGLYAKOV 1988 Volgograd Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 60. 41586/21+* Sofiyskaya c. Rusia 23/07/2021 Yelena Guryevna SOFIYS KAYAAYA 1974 Moscova Moscova 1974 Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 61. 41866/21* Lebedev v. Rusia 21/07/2021 Maksim Aleksandrovich LEBEDEV 1997 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksandrovich MATASOV 62. 4465/21* Lebedev v. Rusia 23/08/2021 Maksim Aleksandrovich LEBEDEV 1997 Nizhniy Novgorod Aleksandrovich MATASOV 63. 44626/21+* Smirnov v. Rusia 20/07/2021 Leonidovich SMIRNOV 1978 Zheleznodorozhnyy Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 64. 44688/21* Congres mondial ucrainean și Vynnyk c. Rusia 26/08/2021 UKRAINIAN World CONGRESS Toronto Sergiy Oleksiyovych VYNNYK 1967 Omsk Nazar Nazar Stepanovych KULCHYTSKYYY 65. 44864/21+* Yefremova c. Rusia 07/08/2021 Irina Sergeyevna YEFREMOVA 1989 Georgie Moscova Eduardovich TEVOSOV 66. 44900/21+* Barinov c. Rusia 20/07/2021 Ivan Borisovich BARINOV 1957 Moscova Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 67. 47495/21* Royzman v. Rusia 08/09/2021 Yevgeniy Vadimovich ROYZMAN 1962 Yekaterinburg Yuliya FEDOTOVA 68. 47901/21+* Ataulin v. Rusia 05/09/2021 Vadim Rafailovich ATAULIN 1980 Moscova Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 69. 48076/21+* Balandin v. Rusia 05/09/2021 Nikolay Lvovich BALANDIN 1983 Moscova Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 70. 48205/21+* Ivanov v. Rusia 05/09/2021 Georgiy Aleksandrovich IVANOV 1995 Georgiul Moscova Eduardovich TEVOSOV 71. 54836/21* Ibragimov v. Rusia 21/10/2021 Denis Irekovich IBRAGIMOV 1996 Chelyabinsk Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 72. 56728/21* Antonova v. Rusia 03/11/2021 Yana Gennadyevna ANTONOVA 1979 Krasnodar Aleksandr Viktorovich VALYAVSKIY 73. 57110/21+* Zabelin v. Rusia 08/11/2021 Maksim Valerievich ZABELIN 1991 Tomsk Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO 74. 59621/21* Yashin v. Rusia 16/11/2021 Ilya Valerievich YASHIN 1983 Moscova Aleksandr Dmitriyevich PEREDRUK 75. 59626/21* Kudryakov v. Rusia 16/11/2021 Lev Vyacheslavovich KUDRYAKOV 1999 Moscova Aleksandr Dmitriyevich PEREDRUK 76. 60110/21* Pchenichkin v. Rusia 20/11/2021 Aleksandr Aleksandrovich PSHENICKIN 1995 Zemtsov Georgiy Eduardovich TEVOSOV 77. 60192/21* Magdalits v. Rusia 25/11/2021 Yevgeniy Vladimirovich MAGDALITS 1992 Moscova Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 78. 1253/22+* Tadey c. Rusia 07/12/2021 Stanislav Viktorovich TADEY 1977 Moscova 79. 5498/22* Zhavoronkov c. Rusia 03/01/2022 Sergey Vladimovich ZHAVORONKOV 1977 Dolgoprudy Aleksey Alekseyevich VASILEV 80. 7131/22+* Galitskiy c. Rusia 16/01/2022 Denis Grigorievich GALITSKIY 1969 Perm 81. 9625/22* Brusova v. Rusia 20/01/2022 Natalya Vladimovna BRUSOVA 1986 Sochi Aleksey Aleksandrovich PRYANISHNIKOV 82. 17919/22+* Glukhov v. Rusia 14/03/2022 Aleksey Vladimovich GLUKHOV 1983 Novocheboksarsk Irina Vladimovna KHRUNOVA 83. 53201/22 Asociația școlilor de studii politice ale Consiliului Europei v. Rusia 05/11/2022 ASSOCIAREA școlilor de studii POLITIQUE ale CONSILIULUI EUROPEI 2008 Strasbourg Kirill Nikolayevich KOROTEEV