BOROVINSKIKH v. RUSSIA and 173 other applications

BOROVINSKIKH v. RUSSIA and 173 other applications (CtEDO, 2023)

Publicat la 16 octombrie 2023 SECȚIUNE TERZĂ Aplicația nr. 50074/18 Petr Anatolyevich BOROVINSKIKH împotriva Rusiei și a altor 173 cereri (a se vedea lista adăugată) comunicată la 29 septembrie 2023 OBIECTUL CAUZEI Cerințele se referă la diferite tipuri de interferențe cu dreptul reclamantului la libertate de exprimare, care pot fi împărțite în cinci grupuri. Grupele 1 și 2 se referă la acuzarea reclamanților în procedurile administrative și penale, respectiv, pentru a împărtăși public informații sau a organiza demonstrații individuale, pe care autoritățile ruse le consideră atenuate imaginea militarului rus sau a deviației din narația oficială a războiului rus împotriva Ucrainei. Grupul 3 se referă la un atac asupra jurnaliștilor într-un tur de presă în Republica Ceceană și la lipsa unei anchete eficace. Grupul 4 se referă la refuzul autorităților ruse de a oferi acces la documentele de arhivă despre victimele represiuni politice în Uniunea Sovietică. Grupul 5 se referă la plângerile de către principalele platforme internet, inclusiv Twitter, Google și Meta, despre amenzi excesive impuse lor pentru faptul că nu au fost eliminate informații care au fost considerate dăunătoare pentru reputația autorităților ruse. : A existat o încălcare a articolului 10 din Convenție din cauza acuzației reclamanților pentru comportamentul lor expresiv? Grupul 3: A existat o încălcare a articolelor 3, 8, 10 din Convenție sau a articolului 1 din Protocolul nr. 1, luate de unul singur sau în conjuncție cu art. 13, privind atacul asupra reclamanților care își desfășoară activitatea jurnalistică, absența unei anchete eficace asupra atacului, furtul articolelor lor personale și echipamente profesionale, arderea unui minibus al reclamanților și a rupt-in în laptop altui solicitant în timpul absenței ei de la hotel? Grupul 4: A existat o încălcare a articolelor 8 sau 10 din Convenție din cauza respingerii cererilor reclamanților de acces la informații în arhivele de stat cu privire la soarta rudelor închise în epoca sovietică, sau la victimele Marii Terori, în scopuri de cercetare? Grupul 5 : A existat o încălcare a articolului 10 din Convenție din cauza urmăririi în judecată a platformelor de presă socială pentru faptul că nu a retras informațiile pe care autoritățile ruse le considerau ilegale sau pentru a restabili accesul la informațiile care încălcau condițiile de utilizare ale platformelor? APENDIX Nr. cerere nr. Denumire de caz Lodged on Name Year of Nasce / Incorporation Place of Residence sau incorporarea reprezentată de Grupul 1 50074/18 Borovinskikh c. Rusia 10/10/2018 Petr Anatolyevich BOROVINSKIKH 1976 Kopeysk Ivan Yurievich ZHDANOV 5942/21 Nogovitsyn c. Rusia 20/11/2021 Anatoliy Grigorievich NOGOVITSYN 1987 Yakutsk Irina Vladimirovna KHRUNOVA 34131/22 Gorinov c. Rusia 23/06/2022 Yevgeniy Gennadyevich GORINOV 1989 Tomsk Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 35604/22 Erdneyev v. Rusia 01/07/2022 Aducha Arankovich ERDNEYEV 1959 Troitskoye Vasilievich SABININ 35641/22 Badmayev v. Rusia 01/07/2022 Valeriy Antonovich BADMAYEV Elista Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 36261/22 Kurg v. Rusia 09/07/2022 Konstantin Vladimirovich KURG 1977 Velikiy Novgorod Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN 36648/22 Trofimov v. Rusia 29/06/2022 Yaroslav Andreyevich TROFIMOV 1995 Krasnodar Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 36757/22 Olyunina v. Rusia 15/07/2022 Alisa Aleksandrovna OLYUNINA 1998 Volgograd Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA 36838/22 Samylova v. Rusia 14/07/2022 Lyubov Sergeyevna SAMILOVA 1999 St Petersburg Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA 36842/22 Klimova v. Rusia 14/07/2022 Kseniya Dmitriyevna KLIMOVA 1997 Volgograd Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA 36875/22 Buyanova v. Rusia 01/07/2022 Valeriya Vladimirovna BUYANOVA 2000 Samara Aleksandra Nikolayevna BAYEVA 37076/22 Pistov v. Rusia 18/07/2022 Mikhail Mikhaylovich PISTSOV 1995 Belyayev Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 37532/22 Chuzayeva v. Rusia 20/07/2022 Mariya Nikolayevna CHUZAYEVA 1999 Arino Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 38123/22 Gorelov și alții v. Rusia 14/07/2022 Nikolay Aleksandrovich GORELOV 1985 Kaliningrad Semen Viktorovich ALEKSIN 1995 Tyumen Valeriya Vladimirovna BUYANOVA 2000 Samara Mariya Gennadyevna PRUTSKOVA 1983 Moscova Olesya Yuryevna TROFIMOVA 1997 Krasnodar Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 39367/22 Grodnikova v. Rusia 22/07/2022 Tamara Ivanovna GRODNIKOVA 1960 Volgograd Roman Olegovich ZAYTSEV 39794/22 Isayeva v. Rusia 30/07/2022 Yevgeniya Maksimovna ISAYEVA 1988 St Petersburg Sergey Viktorovich PODOLSKIY 40288/22 Balakina v. Rusia 25/07/2022 Anastasiya Igorevna BALAKINA 2001 Bor Kristina Olegovna TYURINA 41158/22 Veretennikova v. Rusia 12/08/2022 Marina Viktorovna VERETINIKOVA 1967 Tomsk Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 41428/22 Dorokhov v. Rusia 13/08/2022 Vladimir Yurievich DOROKHOV 1985 Barsuki Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ 42762/22 Mamedov v. Rusia 24/08/2022 Oleg Iskanderovich MAMEDOV 2001 Ufa Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO 43213/22 Burdin v. Rusia 25/08/2022 Viktor Valerievich BURDIN 1972 Nikolskoye Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 43414/22 Priymak v. Rusia 12/08/2022 Kseniya Vitalyevna PRIYMAK 1998 Vladivostok Sergey Aleksandrovich VALIPLIN 43935/22 Sandzhiyev v. Rusia 28/08/2022 Arslang Bambayevich SANDZHIYEV 1960 Barnaul Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 44304/22 Mitrofanov c. Rusia 19/08/2022 Pavel Aleksandrovich MITROFANOV 1991 Yekaterinburg Aleksay Vladimirovich BUSHMAKOV 44505/22 Sokolova c. Rusia 25/08/2022 Svetlana Yuryevna SOKOLOVA 1979 Moscova Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA 446/27/22 Vanin c. Rusia 12/08/2022 Mikhail Sergeyevich VANIN 1982 Tomsk 44796/22 Zelenskiy c. Rusia 23/08/2022 Konstantin Sergeyevich ZELENSKIY 1984 Novorossiysk Aleksey Alekseyevich DUBROVIN 44813/22 Kholkin v. Rusia 26/08/2022 Aleksey Ilyich KHOLKIN 1987 Sylva Matvey Sergeyevich TRUTNEV 44853/22 Semenychev v. Rusia 25/08/2022 Vyacheslav Valeryevich SEMENYCHEV 1984 Nizhniy Novgorod Kristina Olegovna TYURINA 45045/22 Broy v. Rusia 31/08/2022 Andrey Yuryevich BROY 1980 Yaroslavll 4508/22 Aptysheva și alții v. Rusia 25/08/2022 Olga Romanovna APTYSHEVA 1985 Murmansk Konstantin Valerievich NADEIN 1968 Sf. Petersburg Valentina Olegovna POMAZANOVA 2002 Saratov Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 45155/22 Serdiukov v. Rusia 27/08/2022 Aleksandr Vladimirovich SERDYUKOV 1974 Nedvigovka Aleksey Alekseyevich LEVENKO 45909/22 Bondar v. Rusia 23/08/2022 Aleksandr Leonidovich BONDAR 1974 Moscova Mariya Olegovna BONDAR 1976 Moscova Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO 45911/22 Bondar v. Rusia 23/08/2022 Mariya Olegovna BONDAR 1976 Moscova Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO 45937/22 Shelevoy v. Rusia 07/09/2022 Aleksey Leonidovich SHELEVOY 1967 Novokuznetsk Dmitriy Dmitriyevich MIROPOLTSEV 466061/22 Kurkov v. Rusia 03/09/2022 Sergey Aleksandrovich KURKOV 1986 St Petersburg 46317/22 Zhebelev v. Rusia 15/09/2022 Dmitriy Gennadyevich ZHEBELEV 1983 Perm 46499/22 Pavlov v. Rusia 17/09/2022 Kirill Vladimirovich PAVLOV 1971 Velikiy Novgorod Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN 46721/22 Atanchuk v. Rusia 19/09/2022 Vladimir Leonidovich ATAMANCHUK 1951 Sochi 46861/22 Chernyshov v. Rusia 15/09/2022 Andrey Valerievich CHERNISHHOV 1989 St Petersburg Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 46898/22 Shigayeva v. Rusia 16/08/2022 Irina Alekseyevna SHIGAYEVA 1955 Velikiy Novgorod Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN 469/46/22 Selyaninov v. Rusia 07/09/2022 Yevgeniy Vyacheslavovich SELYANINNOV 1971 Perm Andrey Vasilyevich SABINININ 46950/22 Ledkov v. Rusia 07/09/2022 Valeriy Konstantinovich LEDKOV 1965 Khanty-Mansiysk Andrey Vasilyevich SABINININ 471115/22 Dericheva v. Rusia 10/09/2022 Anna Andreyevna DERISHEVA 1999 Izhevsk Viktor Valerievich KOCHENKOV 47544/22 Grigoriev v. Rusia 21/09/2022 Yevgeniy Nikolayevich GRIGORYEV 1977 Velikiy Novgorod Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN 4755/22 Vorobyeva v. Rusia 23/09/2022 Yekaterina Anatolyevna VOROBYEVA 1974 Moscova Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN 47616/22 Nefedov v. Rusia 14/09/2022 Gordey Yurievich NEFEDOV 1978 Moscova Moscova Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA 47690/22 Mamedov v. Rusia 22/09/2022 Dzhavid Elsevar Ogly MAMEDOV 1995 Moscova Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO 47815/22 Kraynyyukov v. Rusia 20/09/2022 Valeriy Vitalievich KRAYNYUKOV 1987 Kerch Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN 47972/22 Blagov v. Rusia 13/09/2022 Daniil Dmitrieyvich BLAGOV 1999 Kaliningrad 48104/22 Yanovskaya v. Rusia 24/09/2022 Yana Vladirovna YANOVSKAYA 1976 Kudymkar Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA 48110/22 Parakhina v. Rusia 24/09/2022 Marina Viktorovna PARAKHINA 1973 Perm Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA 48353/22 Orlov v. Rusia 14/09/2022 Fedor Ivanovich ORLOV 1988 Voronezh Daniil Alekseyevich POLYAKOV 48363/22 Filatova v. Rusia 14/09/2022 Darya Olegovna FILATOVA 2001 Voronezhh Daniil Alekseyevich POLYOV 48958/22 Shlosberg și Shlosberg v. Rusia 30/09/2022 Zhanna Antonovna SHLOSBERG 1966 Pskov Lev Markovich SHLOSBERG 1963 Pskov 49304/22 Litke v. Rusia 07/10/2022 Aleksandr Vladimovich LITKE 1987 Tula Aleksey Valerievich VLASOV 49395/22 Zhunev v. Rusia 06/10/2022 Aleksandr Vitleyevich ZHUNEV 2000 Volgodonsk Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN 499441/22 Volodin v. Rusia 04/10/2022 Aleksey Ivanovich VOLODIN 1976 Safonovovo Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ 49447/22 Ardakhanova v. Rusia 01/10/2022 Albina Raisovna ARDAKHANOVA 1992 Naberezhnyye Chelny Rim Faridovich SABIROV 49746/22 Zhukov v. Rusia 26/09/2022 Nikolay Dmitriyevich ZHUKOV 2000 Tolyatti Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 50086/22 Naydenova v. Rusia 12/10/2022 Aleksandra Olegovna NAYDENOVA 2003 Moscova Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO 50237/22 Kalashnikov v. Rusia 08/10/2022 Viktor Vladimirovich KALASHNIKOV 1995 Krasnoyarsk Vladimir Valerievich VASIN 50632/22 Ziv v. Rusia 07/10/2022 Anna Mikhaylovna ZIV 1981 St Petersburg Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA 50678/22 Overkin v. Rusia 19/10/2022 Sergey Yevgenyevich OVERKIN 1970 Pskov Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 50701/22 Kaburkina v. Rusia 20/10/2022 Yuliya Anatolyevna KABURKINA 1986 Cheboksary Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 50921/22 Nurgaleyev v. Rusia 30/09/2022 Ilyas Nurlislanovich NURGALEYEV 1976 Samara Yelena Vladimirovna LIPATOVA 50927/22 Novikova v. Rusia 06/10/2022 Yevgeniya Aleksandrovna NOVIKOVA 1985 Moscova Natalya Aleksandrovna VUNDER 51103/22 Andryushchenko și alții v. Rusia 30/09/2022 Oleg Viktorovich ANDRYUSCHENKO 1987 Moscova Darya Andreyevna DEMYANCHUK 1997 Krasnoyarsk Yegor Nikolayevich VAZHIN 1994 Yaroslavl Yuliya Igorevna YELISEYEVA 1994 Ulyanovsk Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 51276/22 Gorbunov v. Rusia 22/10/2022 Vasiliy Grigorievich GORBUNOV 1987 Volgodonsk Andrey Vasilyevich SABIN 51325/22 Otradnov v. Rusia 01/10/2022 Dmitriy Vladimirovich OTRADNOV 1993 Kachkanar Aleksey Vladimirovich BUSHMAKOV 51396/22 Mozheyko v. Rusia 22/10/2022 Lev Viktorovich MOZHEYKO 1972 Cheboksary Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 51420/22 Grekhov v. Rusia 21/10/2022 Viktor Anatolyevich GREKHOV 1977 Moscova Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA 51651/22 Pavlin v. Rusia 22/10/2022 Andrey Nikolayevich PAVLININ 1972 Nezhdaninskoye Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 51731/22 Potemkin v. Rusia 20/10/2022 Danila Ivanovich POTEMKIN 2000 Tomsk 51810/22 Bespokoyev v. Rusia 21/10/2022 Demyan Vladimirovich BESPOOYEV 2001 St Petersburg Yana Andreyevna NEPOVINNOVA 52056/22 Savinkinina v. Rusia 21/10/2022 Tatyana Ivanovna SAVINKINA 1945 Petrozavodsk Nataliya Nikolayevna CERNOVA 52370/22 Gorbachev v. Rusia 01/10/2022 Denis Alekseyevich GORBACHEV 1988 Voronezh Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA 52880/22 Nosov v. Rusia 17/10/2022 Aleksey Viktorovich NOSOV 1975 Seversk Yelena Vladimirovna LIPATOVA 52933/22 Kharitonova v. Rusia 21/10/2022 Yekaterina Sergeyevna KHARITONOVA 1986 Ivanovo Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 53414/22 Salnikov v. Rusia 26/10/2022 Dmitriy Yuryevich SALNIKOV 1980 Pskov Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 5303/22 Durmanov v. Rusia 14/10/2022 Aleksey Sergeyvich DURMANOV 2001 Seltso Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 53823/22 Malinovskiy c. Rusia 26/10/2022 Sergey Aleksandrovich MALINOVSKIY 1993 St Petersburg Luiza Magomedovna MAGOMEDOVA 54147/22 Sukhorukov c. Rusia 10/11/2022 Vladimir Nikolayevich SUKHORUKOV 1963 Pechory Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 54508/22 Latypov c. Rusia 09/11/2022 Robert Ramilevich LATYPOV 1973 Perm Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA 54550/22 Gorina v. Rusia 03/11/2022 Galina Mikhaylovna GORINA 1960 Chelyabinsk 55435/22 Chernyshov și alții v. Rusia 28/10/2022 Andrey Anatolyevich CHERNISHOV 1972 Moscova Artemiy Sergeyevich BOBROV 1992 Moscova Yekaterina Anatolyevna LITVINENKO 1975 Balashikha Kristina Petrovna MARKUS 1984 Moscova Aleksandr Vadimovich METS 1979 Moscova Aleksandr Gennadyevich SAFONOV 1984 Chita Mariya Andreyevna YEVDOKOVA 1984 Moscova Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 55531/22 Otkhonov v. Rusia 13/11/2022 Oleg Andreyevich OTKHONOV 1964 Elista Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 55537/22 Gorodiskiy v. Rusia 13/11/2022 Ivan Mikhaylovich GORODISKIY 1975 Kamenka Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 55543/22 Bashmakova v. Rusia 13/11/2022 Vera Yevgenyevna BASHMAKOVA 1984 Moscova Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 55546/22 Zhebelev v. Rusia 10/11/2022 Dmitriy Gennadyevich ZHEBELEV 1983 Perm 55557/22 Novikova v. Rusia 08/11/2022 Tatyana Vladimirovna NOVIKOVA 1986 Nizhniy Novgorod Kristina Olegovna TYURINA 55702/22 Kharlamov v. Rusia 22/11/2022 Sergey Aleksandrovich KHARLAMOV 1985 Moscova 55820/22 Berdnikov v. Rusia 19/11/2022 Dmitriy Nikolayevich BERDNIKOV 2000 Perm Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 5608/22 Famiyev v. Rusia 20/11/2022 Nafik Akhnafovich FAMIYEV 1960 Yekaterinburg Yuliya Yevgenyevna FEDOTOVA 56087/22 Alekhin v. Rusia 18/11/2022 Yevgeniy Vyacheslavovich ALEKHIN 1976 Moscova Ilnur Ilgizovich SHARAPOV 56627/22 Brosse v. Rusia 27/11/2022 Stepan Viktorovich BROSSE 1993 Cheboksary Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 57019/22 Kuznetsova v. Rusia 13/11/2022 Tatyana Leonidovna KUZNETSOVA 1970 Lahdenpohja Mariya Sergeyevna ZYRYANOVA 57024/22 Vostrov v. Rusia 20/11/2022 Vadim Yevgenyevich VOSTROV 1972 Krasnoyarsk Vladimir Valerievich VASIN 57567/22 Mezin și alții v. Rusia 18/11/2022 Mikhail Yefimovich MEZIN 1965 St Petersburg Denis Alekseievich GORBACHEV 1988 Voronezh Dmitriy Alwksandrovich SMELYY 1976 Shopino Yelizaveta Romanovna TSENKER 1997 Elektrostal Andrey Petrovich ZAKHOBA 1981 Moscova Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 57577/22 Giricheva v. Rusia 19/11/2022 Marina Antonovna GIRICHEVA 1999 Nizhniy Novgorod Konstantin Mikhaylovich ZINOVYEV 57580/22 Titov v. Rusia 02/12/2022 Aleksandr Vyacheslavovich TITOV 1977 Yekaterinburg Sergey Yurievich TIINOV 57642/22 Chernyakevich v. Rusia 05/12/2022 Marina Nikolayevna CHERNYAKEVICH 1991 Moscova Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 57672/22 Glushkov c. Rusia 02/12/2022 Aleksey Alekseyevich GLUSHKOV 1964 Petrozavodsk Nataliya Nikolayevna CERNOVA 57857/22 Kuznetsov c. Rusia 28/11/2022 Aleksey Fedorovich KUZNETSOV 1961 Tula Aleksey Valerievich VLASOV 121/23 Kislyakova c. Rusia 11/11/2022 Anna Alekseyevna KISLYAKOVA 2003 Yekaterinburg Artem Mikeyovich MEDVEDEV 1989 Khimki Dmitriy Vladimovich ZHMYREV 1989 Inzhavino Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 280/23 Kulikovskaya c. Rusia 28/11/2022 Darya Aleksandrovna KULIKOVSKAYA 1991 Azov Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 320/23 Kozhinskaya c. Rusia 14/11/2022 Mariya Aleksandrovna KOZHINSKAYA 1980 Moscova Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 451/23 Kozicheva c. Rusia 26/11/2022 Aleksandra Vladimirovna KOZICHEVA 1996 St Petersburg Mariya Sergeyevna ZYRYANOva 464/23 Olkhova c. Rusia 18/11/2022 Olga Aleksandrovna OLKHOVA 1984 Mayskiy Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 476/23 Grigoriev v. Rusia 18/11/2022 Aleksey Vyacheslavovich GRIGORYEV 1977 Petrozavodsk Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 860/23 Moyseyenko v. Rusia 20/11/2022 Georgiy Mefodievich MOYSEYENKO 1936 Syktyvkar Vladislav Vladislav Vladilovich KoSNYREV 1189/23 Shchekin v. Rusia 08/12/2022 Artem Valentinovich SHCHEKIN 1974 Novosibirsk 1200/23 Olkhovik v. Rusia 02/12/2022 Oleg Aleksandrovich OLKHOVIK 1992 Uspenskoye Feliks Yevgenyevich VERTEGEL 1385/23 Bezaziyeva v. Rusia 09/12/2022 Susana Rasymivna BEZAZIYEVA 1979 Dzhankoy Jessica GAVRON 1403/23 Pavlov v. Rusia 21/12/2022 Roman Sergeyevich PAVLOV 1976 Glazov 1517/23 Pishchalnikov v. Rusia 16/12/2022 Aleksandr Sergeyevich PISHCHALNIKOV 1968 Moscova Moscova Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA 1569/23 Malegin v. Rusia 15/12/2022 Vladimir Dmitriyevich MALEGIIN 1945 Petrozavodsk Anatoliy Vadimovich ALEKSANDROVSKIY 1572/23 Vediagina v. Rusia 15/12/2022 Zhanna Valentinovna VEDYAGINA 1964 Petrozavodsk 1699/23 Chubinidze v. Rusia 10/12/2022 Ketino Borisovna CHUBINIDZE 1993 Moscova 1750/23 Samusev v. Rusia 10/12/2022 Sergey Aleksandrovich SAMUSOV 1978 San Petersburg Leonidovich KRIKUN 2006/23 Samorodskaya v. Rusia 09/12/2022 Mariya Aleksandrovna SAMORODSKAYA 1976 Sosnovoborsk Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA 2023/23 Gutsev v. Rusia 08/12/2022 Aleksandr Viktorovich GUTSEV 1975 Chelyabinsk Andrey Gennadyevich LEPEKHIN 2084/23 Ivanov v. Rusia 05/01/2023 Aleksandr Yuryevich IVANOV 1976 Kaluga Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN 2088/23 Klyuchko v. Rusia 27/12/2022 Yelena Nikolayevna KLYUCHKO 1980 Kebanyel Kirill Yevgenyevich ERLIKHMAN 2144/23 Kulesh v. Rusia 14/12/2022 Ivan Pavlovich KULESH 1994 Delft, Olanda Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 2867/23 Lyubimov și alții v. Rusia 02/12/2022 Ivan Leonidovich LYUBIMOV 1985 Yekaterinburg Anastasiya Aleksandrovna FEYGINA 2002 Ryazan Artem Eduardovich KALLAS 1991 TambovOS Boris Mikhaylovich SHEPELYUK 2002 Moscova Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 3112/23 Matalytskiy c. Rusia 26/12/2022 Artem Yuryevich MATALYTSKIY 1985 Belorechensk 3116/23 OOO Tekhnotorg c. Rusia 31/12/2022 OOO TEKHNOTORG 2009 Yekaterinburg 3733/23 Litvenko c. Rusia 16/12/2022 Pavel Ilichi LITVINENKO 1997 Balashikha Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 3836/23 Salmina c. Rusia 24/12/2022 Kseniya Maksudovna SALMINA 1997 Tolyatti 4802/23 Levina v. Rusia 06/01/2023 Svetlana Igorevna LEVINA 1991 Ryazan Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN 4828/23 Krasilnikov și alții v. Rusia 28/12/2022 Mark Nikolayevich KRASILNIKOV 1992 Yekaterinburg Olga Mikhaylovna SVALOVA 1956 Moscova Ilya Yevgenyevich YERMIN 1982 Volzhskiy Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 4920/23 Akhunov v. Rusia 13/01/2023 Dzhamil Ildarovich AKHUNOV 1994 Kazan Rim Faridovich SABIROV 5107/23 Ispodina v. Rusia 14/01/2023 Galina Petrovna ISPODINA 1961 Medvezhyegorsk Nataliya Nikolayevna CHERNOVA 5369/23 Tanakov v. Rusia 13/01/2023 Pavel Yevgenyevich TANAKOV 1991 Kemerovo Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN 6879/23 Yevtuchenko v. Rusia 20/01/2023 Anna Timofeevna YevTUSHENKO 1994 New York City, NY, USA Olga Yuryevna NECHAYEVA 7437/23 Motsak v. Rusia 23/12/2022 Aleksey Viktorovich MOTSAK 1982 Tashkent Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV 7446/23 Livadnaya și Vasilyev v. Rusia 06/01/2023 Irina Valeryevna LIVADNAYA 1980 Moscova Konstantin Olegovich VASILYEV 1987 Khimki Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 7824/23 Balyasin v. Rusia 14/01/2023 Roman Alekseyevich BALYNASIN 1981 Zheleznogorsk Vladimir Valerievich VASIN 8102/23 Arinichev v. Rusia 16/12/2022 Vladislav Vitalievich ARINICHEV 1993 Druzhba 8961/23 Dubyaga v. Rusia 03/02/2023 Aleksandr Sergeyevich DUBYAGA 1984 Chelyabinsk Andrey Gennadyevich LEPEKHIN 9050/23 Yermilov v. Rusia 20/01/2023 Aleksey Vladimirovich YERMILOV 1974 St Petersburg Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA 10176/23 Kovin v. Rusia 11/02/2023 Vitaliy Sergeyevich KOVIN 1970 Perm Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 10361/23 Kalegin v. Russia 10/02/2023 Yegor Vladimirovich KALEGIN 2001 Asest Kristina Olegovna TYURINA 11179/23 Arbuzenko v. Rusia 27/02/2023 Oksana Ivanovna ARBUZENKO 1980 Tolyatti Andrey Vasilevich SABININ 11255/23 Prudovskaya v. Rusia 08/02/2023 Lidiya Dmitriyevna PRUDOVS KAYA 1976 Mirnyy Andrey Vasilevich SABININ 11258/23 Petkiyev v. Rusia 08/02/2023 Sergey Sergeyevich PETKIYEV 1993 Elista Andrey Vasilievich SABININ 12225/23 Morev v. Rusia 28/02/2023 Andrey Zinovievich MOREV 1974 Moscova Ilgur Ilgizovich SHARAPOV 1323/23 Krasnoperov v. Rusia 21/03/2023 Dmitriy Vladimirovich KRASNOPEROV 1985 Moscova 13844/23 Krivtova și Vorobieva v. Rusia 07/03/2023 Nikolay Aleksandrovich KRIVTOV 1991 Moscova Anna Viktorovna VOROBYEVA 1986 Moscova Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 14506/23 Lyubimov și Latushkin v. Rusia 24/02/2023 Ivan Leonidovich LYUBIMOV 1985 Yekaterinburg Artem Igorevich LATUSHKIN 1985 Moscova Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 14801/23 Saltevskiy v. Rusia 16/03/2023 Vladimir Aleksandrovich SALTEVSKIY 1986 Novosibirsk Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA 16275/23 Vinogradova v. Rusia 30/03/2023 Katerina Aleksandrovna VINOGRADOVA 1989 Novosibirsk Olga Yuryevna NECHAYEVA 16701/23 Kuksina v. Rusia 05/04/2023 Nataliya Sergeyevna KUKSINA 1978 Moscova Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO 16711/23 Chebotar v. Rusia 30/03/2023 Ivan Kirillovich CHEBOTAR 1986 St Petersburg Nikifor Yurievich IVANOV 16717/23 Baltrukov v. Rusia 30/03/2023 Dmitri Nikolayevich BALTRUKOV 1979 St Petersburg Nikifor Yuryevich IVANOV 16721/23 Kiseleva c. Rusia 30/03/2023 Anna Sergeyevna KISELEVA 1985 St Petersburg Nikievn Yuryevich IVANOV 17386/23 Goldina c. Rusia 06/04/2023 Katalisa Sergeyevna GOLDINA 1972 Novosibirsk Olga Yurievna NECHHAYEVA 30201/23 Pshenichnikova c. Rusia 19/06/2023 Emiliya Minibayevna PSHENICNIKOVA 1986 Ufa Irina Vadimovna SERGEYEVA Group 2 9512/22 Prokudin c. Rusia 12/02/20222 Aleksandr Sergeyevich PROKUDIN 1990 Tver Mansur Idrisovich GILMANOV 43083/22 Kara-Murza c. Rusia 24/08/2022 Vladimir Vladimir OTTY 45953/22 Skochilenko c. Rusia 28/07/2022 Aleksandra Yurievna SKOCHILENKO 1990 St Petersburg Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA 48520/22 Afanasyev v. Rusia 07/10/2022 Mikhail Vyacheslavovich AFANASIEV 1976 Abakan Tumas Arsenovich MISAKYAN 57229/22 Naki v. Rusia 02/12/2022 Maykl Sidney NAKI 1993 Moscova Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV Grupul 3 49918/19 Vanslova și alții v. Rusia 18/09/2019 Yekaterina Mikhaylovna VANSLOVA 1990 Nizhniy Novgorod Ivan Vladimovich ZHILTSOV 1982 Nizhniy Novgorod Anton Vladimovich PRUSOV 1983 Nizhniy Novgorod Mikhail Mikhaylovich SOLUNIN 1988 Nizhniy Novgorod Bashir Izralovich PLIYEV 1968 Pliyevo Olga Aleksandrovna SADOVS KAYA 51424/19 Yelagina și alții v. Rusia 18/09/2019 Aleksandrina Vyacheșlavovna YELAGINA 1991 Moscova Nikita Andreyevich PROTSENKO 1987 Moscova Oystein WINDSTAD 1983 Oslo, Norvegia Kirill Nikolayevich KOROTEEV Group 4 29440/19 Dupuy v. Rusia 17/05/2019 Elsa Marie DUPUY 1952 Lausanne, Elveția Ivan Yurievich PAVLOV 12396/21 Kulakova și alții c. Rusia 28/01/2021 Yevgeniya Yurievna KULAKOVA 1988 St Petersburg Olga Nikolayevna STARTSEVA 1990 St Petersburg Yelena Igorevna KONDRAKHINA 1987 Kolpino Olga Nikolayevna STARTSEVA 61350/21 Prudovskiy c. Rusia 08/12/2021 Sergey Boriovich PRUDOVSKIY 1949 Moscova ASISTENȚAL DREPTURILE HUMANE CENTRE 25390/22 Memorial Internațional v. Rusia 28/04/2022 ASISTENT INTERNAȚIONAL 1991 Moscova ASISTENTAL FRANCE Group 5 57131/21 Twitter, Inc. v. Rusia 18/11/2021 TWITTER, INC. 2007 San Francisco, CA, SUA Jonathan PRICE 9177/22 Meta Platformes, Inc. v. Rusia 28/01/2022 META PLATFORMS, INC. Menlo Park, CA, SUA Maya LESTER 37027/22 OOO Google și alții v. Rusia 27/07/2022 OOO GOOOGLE 2005 Moscova, Rusia GOOGLE IRLAND LTD 2003 Dublin, Irlanda GOOGLE INTERNATIONAL LLC 2002 Wilmington, DE, SUA GOOGLE LLC 2002 Wilmington, DE, SUA Timothy OTTY

Published on 16 October 2023

THIRD SECTION

Application no. 50074/18

Petr Anatolyevich BOROVINSKIKH against Russia

and 173 other applications

(see list appended)

communicated on 29 September 2023

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

The applications concern various types of interference with the applicants’ right to freedom of expression, which can be divided into five groups.

Groups 1 and 2 concern the applicants’ prosecution in administrative and criminal proceedings, respectively, for publicly sharing information or staging solo demonstrations, which the Russian authorities considered to be tarnishing the image of the Russian military or deviating from the official narrative of Russia’s war against Ukraine.

Group 3 concerns an attack on journalists during a press tour to the Chechen Republic and the lack of an effective investigation.

Group 4 concerns the Russian authorities’ refusal to provide access to archival documents about the victims of political repression in the Soviet Union.

Group 5 concerns complaints by major Internet platforms, including Twitter, Google, and Meta, about excessive fines imposed on them for failure to remove information which was considered damaging to the reputation of the Russian authorities.

QUESTIONS TO THE PARTIES

Groups 1 and 2

: Has there been a violation of Article 10 of the Convention on account of the applicants’ prosecution for their expressive conduct?

Group 3

: Has there been a violation of Articles 3, 8, 10 of the Convention or Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, taken on their own or in conjunction with Article 13, relating to the attack on the applicants who were carrying out their journalistic work, the absence of an effective investigation into the attack, the theft of their personal items and professional equipment, the burning of one of the applicants’ minibus, and the break-in into another applicant’s laptop during her absence from the hotel?

Group 4

: Has there been a violation of Articles 8 or 10 of the Convention due to the rejection of the applicants’ requests to access information in the State archives about the fates of relatives imprisoned during the Soviet era, or about the victims of the Great Terror, for research purposes?

Group 5

: Has there been a violation of Article 10 of the Convention on account of the prosecution of social media platforms for failing to take down the information which the Russian authorities deemed unlawful or to restore access to the information which breached the platforms’ terms of use?

APPENDIX

No.

Application no.

Case name

Lodged on

Name

Year of Birth / Incorporation

Place of Residence

or Incorporation

Represented by

Group 1

1

50074/18

Borovinskikh v.

Russia

10/10/2018

Petr Anatolyevich BOROVINSKIKH

1976

Kopeysk

Ivan Yuryevich ZHDANOV

59429/21

Nogovitsyn v.

Russia

20/11/2021

Anatoliy Grigoryevich NOGOVITSYN

1987

Yakutsk

Irina Vladimirovna KHRUNOVA

34131/22

Gorinov v.

Russia

23/06/2022

Yevgeniy Gennadyevich GORINOV

1989

Tomsk

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

35604/22

Erdneyev v.

Russia

01/07/2022

Aducha Arankovich ERDNEYEV

1959

Troitskoye

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

35641/22

Badmayev v.

Russia

01/07/2022

Valeriy Antonovich BADMAYEV

Elista

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

36261/22

Kurg v.

Russia

09/07/2022

Konstantin Vladimirovich KURG

1977

Velikiy Novgorod

Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN

36648/22

Trofimov v.

Russia

29/06/2022

Yaroslav Andreyevich TROFIMOV

1995

Krasnodar

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

36757/22

Olyunina v.

Russia

15/07/2022

Alisa Aleksandrovna OLYUNINA

1998

Volgograd

Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA

36838/22

Samylova v.

Russia

14/07/2022

Lyubov Sergeyevna SAMYLOVA

1999

St Petersburg

Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA

36842/22

Klimova v.

Russia

14/07/2022

Kseniya Dmitriyevna KLIMOVA

1997

Volgograd

Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA

36875/22

Buyanova v.

Russia

01/07/2022

Valeriya Vladimirovna

BUYANOVA

2000

Samara

Aleksandra Nikolayevna BAYEVA

37076/22

Pistsov v.

Russia

18/07/2022

Mikhail Mikhaylovich PISTSOV

1995

Belyayev

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

37532/22

Chuzayeva v.

Russia

20/07/2022

Mariya Nikolayevna CHUZAYEVA

1999

Arino

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

38123/22

Gorelov and Others v.

Russia

14/07/2022

Nikolay Aleksandrovich GORELOV

1985

Kaliningrad

Semen Viktorovich ALEKSIN

1995

Tyumen

Valeriya Vladimirovna BUYANOVA

2000

Samara

Mariya Gennadyevna PRUTSKOVA

1983

Moscow

Olesya Yuryevna TROFIMOVA

1997

Krasnodar

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

39367/22

Grodnikova v.

Russia

22/07/2022

Tamara Ivanovna GRODNIKOVA

1960

Volgograd

Roman Olegovich ZAYTSEV

39794/22

Isayeva v.

Russia

30/07/2022

Yevgeniya Maksimovna ISAYEVA

1988

St Petersburg

Sergey Viktorovich PODOLSKIY

40288/22

Balakina v.

Russia

25/07/2022

Anastasiya Igorevna BALAKINA

2001

Bor

Kristina Olegovna TYURINA

41158/22

Veretennikova v.

Russia

12/08/2022

Marina Viktorovna VERETENNIKOVA

1967

Tomsk

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

41428/22

Dorokhov v.

Russia

13/08/2022

Vladimir Yuryevich DOROKHOV

1985

Barsuki

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

42762/22

Mamedov v.

Russia

24/08/2022

Oleg Iskanderovich MAMEDOV

2001

Ufa

Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO

43213/22

Burdin v.

Russia

25/08/2022

Viktor Valeryevich BURDIN

1972

Nikolskoye

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

43414/22

Priymak v.

Russia

12/08/2022

Kseniya Vitalyevna PRIYMAK

1998

Vladivostok

Sergey Aleksandrovich VALIULIN

43935/22

Sandzhiyev v.

Russia

28/08/2022

Arslang Bambayevich SANDZHIYEV

1960

Barnaul

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

44304/22

Mitrofanov v.

Russia

19/08/2022

Pavel Aleksandrovich MITROFANOV

1991

Yekaterinburg

Aleksey Vladimirovich BUSHMAKOV

44505/22

Sokolova v.

Russia

25/08/2022

Svetlana Yuryevna SOKOLOVA

1979

Moscow

Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA

44627/22

Vanin v.

Russia

12/08/2022

Mikhail Sergeyevich VANIN

1982

Tomsk

44796/22

Zelenskiy v.

Russia

23/08/2022

Konstantin Sergeyevich ZELENSKIY

1984

Novorossiysk

Aleksey Alekseyevich DUBROVIN

44813/22

Kholkin v.

Russia

26/08/2022

Aleksey Ilyich KHOLKIN

1987

Sylva

Matvey Sergeyevich TRUTNEV

44853/22

Semenychev v.

Russia

25/08/2022

Vyacheslav Valeryevich SEMENYCHEV

1984

Nizhniy Novgorod

Kristina Olegovna TYURINA

45045/22

Broy v.

Russia

31/08/2022

Andrey Yuryevich BROY

1980

Yaroslavl

45083/22

Aptysheva and Others v.

Russia

25/08/2022

Olga Romanovna APTYSHEVA

1985

Murmansk

Konstantin Valeryevich NADEIN

1968

St Petersburg

Valentina Olegovna POMAZANOVA

2002

Saratov

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

45155/22

Serdyukov v.

Russia

27/08/2022

Aleksandr Vladimirovich SERDYUKOV

1974

Nedvigovka

Aleksey Alekseyevich LEVCHENKO

45909/22

Bondar v.

Russia

23/08/2022

Aleksandr Leonidovich BONDAR

1974

Moscow

Mariya Olegovna BONDAR

1976

Moscow

Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO

45911/22

Bondar v.

Russia

23/08/2022

Mariya Olegovna BONDAR

1976

Moscow

Nikolay Sergeyevich ZBOROSHENKO

45937/22

Shelevoy v.

Russia

07/09/2022

Aleksey Leonidovich SHELEVOY

1967

Novokuznetsk

Dmitriy Dmitriyevich MIROPOLTSEV

46061/22

Kurkov v.

Russia

03/09/2022

Sergey Aleksandrovich KURKOV

1986

St Petersburg

46317/22

Zhebelev v.

Russia

15/09/2022

Dmitriy Gennadyevich ZHEBELEV

1983

Perm

46499/22

Pavlov v.

Russia

17/09/2022

Kirill Vladimirovich PAVLOV

1971

Velikiy Novgorod

Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN

46721/22

Atamanchuk v.

Russia

19/09/2022

Vladimir Leonidovich ATAMANCHUK

1951

Sochi

46861/22

Chernyshov v.

Russia

15/09/2022

Andrey Valeryevich CHERNYSHOV

1989

St Petersburg

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

46898/22

Shigayeva v.

Russia

16/08/2022

Irina Alekseyevna SHIGAYEVA

1955

Velikiy Novgorod

Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN

46946/22

Selyaninov v.

Russia

07/09/2022

Yevgeniy Vyacheslavovich SELYANINOV

1971

Perm

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

46950/22

Ledkov v.

Russia

07/09/2022

Valeriy Konstantinovich LEDKOV

1965

Khanty-Mansiysk

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

47115/22

Derisheva v.

Russia

10/09/2022

Anna Andreyevna DERISHEVA

1999

Izhevsk

Viktor Valeryevich KOCHENKOV

47544/22

Grigoryev v.

Russia

21/09/2022

Yevgeniy Nikolayevich GRIGORYEV

1977

Velikiy Novgorod

Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN

47555/22

Vorobyeva v.

Russia

23/09/2022

Yekaterina Anatolyevna VOROBYEVA

1974

Moscow

Konstantin Aleksandrovich MARKIN

47616/22

Nefedov v.

Russia

14/09/2022

Gordey Yuryevich NEFEDOV

1978

Moscow

Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA

47690/22

Mamedov v.

Russia

22/09/2022

Dzhavid Elsevar Ogly MAMEDOV

1995

Moscow

Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO

47815/22

Kraynyukov v.

Russia

20/09/2022

Valeriy Vitalyevich KRAYNYUKOV

1987

Kerch

Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN

47972/22

Blagov v.

Russia

13/09/2022

Daniil Dmitrieyvich

BLAGOV

1999

Kaliningrad

48104/22

Yanovskaya v.

Russia

24/09/2022

Yana Vladimirovna YANOVSKAYA

1976

Kudymkar

Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA

48110/22

Parakhina v.

Russia

24/09/2022

Marina Viktorovna PARAKHINA

1973

Perm

Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA

48353/22

Orlov v.

Russia

14/09/2022

Fedor Ivanovich ORLOV

1988

Voronezh

Daniil Alekseyevich POLYAKOV

48363/22

Filatova v.

Russia

14/09/2022

Darya Olegovna FILATOVA

2001

Voronezh

Daniil Alekseyevich POLYAKOV

48958/22

Shlosberg and Shlosberg v.

Russia

30/09/2022

Zhanna Antonovna SHLOSBERG

1966

Pskov

Lev Markovich SHLOSBERG

1963

Pskov

49304/22

Litke v.

Russia

07/10/2022

Aleksandr Vladimirovich LITKE

1987

Tula

Aleksey Valeryevich VLASOV

49395/22

Zhunev v.

Russia

06/10/2022

Aleksandr Vitalyevich ZHUNEV

2000

Volgodonsk

Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN

49441/22

Volodin v.

Russia

04/10/2022

Aleksey Ivanovich VOLODIN

1976

Safonovo

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

49447/22

Ardakhanova v.

Russia

01/10/2022

Albina Raisovna ARDAKHANOVA

1992

Naberezhnyye Chelny

Rim Faridovich SABIROV

49746/22

Zhukov v.

Russia

26/09/2022

Nikolay Dmitriyevich ZHUKOV

2000

Tolyatti

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

50086/22

Naydenova v.

Russia

12/10/2022

Aleksandra Olegovna NAYDENOVA

2003

Moscow

Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO

50237/22

Kalashnikov v.

Russia

08/10/2022

Viktor Vladimirovich KALASHNIKOV

1995

Krasnoyarsk

Vladimir Valeryevich VASIN

50632/22

Ziv v.

Russia

07/10/2022

Anna Mikhaylovna ZIV

1981

St Petersburg

Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA

50678/22

Overkin v.

Russia

19/10/2022

Sergey Yevgenyevich OVERKIN

1970

Pskov

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

50701/22

Kaburkina v.

Russia

20/10/2022

Yuliya Anatolyevna KABURKINA

1986

Cheboksary

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

50921/22

Nurgaleyev v.

Russia

30/09/2022

Ilyas Nurlislanovich NURGALEYEV

1976

Samara

Yelena Vladimirovna LIPATOVA

50927/22

Novikova v.

Russia

06/10/2022

Yevgeniya Aleksandrovna NOVIKOVA

1985

Moscow

Natalya Aleksandrovna VUNDER

51103/22

Andryushchenko and Others v.

Russia

30/09/2022

Oleg Viktorovich ANDRYUSHCHENKO

1987

Moscow

Darya Andreyevna DEMYANCHUK

1997

Krasnoyarsk

Yegor Nikolayevich VAZHIN

1994

Yaroslavl

Yuliya Igorevna YELISEYEVA

1994

Ulyanovsk

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

51276/22

Gorbunov v.

Russia

22/10/2022

Vasiliy Grigoryevich GORBUNOV

1987

Volgodonsk

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

51325/22

Otradnov v.

Russia

01/10/2022

Dmitriy Vladimirovich OTRADNOV

1993

Kachkanar

Aleksey Vladimirovich BUSHMAKOV

51396/22

Mozheyko v.

Russia

22/10/2022

Lev Viktorovich MOZHEYKO

1972

Cheboksary

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

51420/22

Grekhov v.

Russia

21/10/2022

Viktor Anatolyevich GREKHOV

1977

Moscow

Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA

51651/22

Pavlinin v.

Russia

22/10/2022

Andrey Nikolayevich PAVLININ

1972

Nezhdaninskoye

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

51731/22

Potemkin v.

Russia

20/10/2022

Danila Ivanovich POTEMKIN

2000

Tomsk

51810/22

Bespokoyev v.

Russia

21/10/2022

Demyan Vladimirovich BESPOKOYEV

2001

St Petersburg

Yana Andreyevna NEPOVINNOVA

52056/22

Savinkina v.

Russia

21/10/2022

Tatyana Ivanovna SAVINKINA

1945

Petrozavodsk

Nataliya Nikolayevna CHERNOVA

52370/22

Gorbachev v.

Russia

01/10/2022

Denis Alekseyevich GORBACHEV

1988

Voronezh

Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA

52880/22

Nosov v.

Russia

17/10/2022

Aleksey Viktorovich NOSOV

1975

Seversk

Yelena Vladimirovna LIPATOVA

52933/22

Kharitonova v.

Russia

21/10/2022

Yekaterina Sergeyevna KHARITONOVA

1986

Ivanovo

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

53414/22

Salnikov v.

Russia

26/10/2022

Dmitriy Yuryevich SALNIKOV

1980

Pskov

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

53603/22

Durmanov v.

Russia

14/10/2022

Aleksey Sergeyvich DURMANOV

2001

Seltso

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

53823/22

Malinovskiy v.

Russia

26/10/2022

Sergey Aleksandrovich MALINOVSKIY

1993

St Petersburg

Luiza Magomedovna MAGOMEDOVA

54147/22

Sukhorukov v.

Russia

10/11/2022

Vladimir Nikolayevich SUKHORUKOV

1963

Pechory

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

54508/22

Latypov v.

Russia

09/11/2022

Robert Ramilevich LATYPOV

1973

Perm

Yelena Yuryevna PERSHAKOVA

54550/22

Gorina v.

Russia

03/11/2022

Galina Mikhaylovna GORINA

1960

Chelyabinsk

55435/22

Chernyshov and Others v.

Russia

28/10/2022

Andrey Anatolyevich CHERNYSHOV

1972

Moscow

Artemiy Sergeyevich BOBROV

1992

Moscow

Yekaterina Anatolyevna LITVINENKO

1975

Balashikha

Kristina Petrovna MARKUS

1984

Moscow

Aleksandr Vadimovich METS

1979

Moscow

Aleksandr Gennadyevich SAFONOV

1984

Chita

Mariya Andreyevna YEVDOKIMOVA

1984

Moscow

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

55531/22

Otkhonov v.

Russia

13/11/2022

Oleg Andreyevich OTKHONOV

1964

Elista

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

55537/22

Gorodiskiy v.

Russia

13/11/2022

Ivan Mikhaylovich GORODISKIY

1975

Kamenka

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

55543/22

Bashmakova v.

Russia

13/11/2022

Vera Yevgenyevna BASHMAKOVA

1984

Moscow

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

55546/22

Zhebelev v.

Russia

10/11/2022

Dmitriy Gennadyevich ZHEBELEV

1983

Perm

55557/22

Novikova v.

Russia

08/11/2022

Tatyana Vladimirovna NOVIKOVA

1986

Nizhniy Novgorod

Kristina Olegovna TYURINA

55702/22

Kharlamov v.

Russia

22/11/2022

Sergey Aleksandrovich KHARLAMOV

1985

Moscow

55820/22

Berdnikov v.

Russia

19/11/2022

Dmitriy Nikolayevich BERDNIKOV

2000

Perm

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

56008/22

Famiyev v.

Russia

20/11/2022

Nafik Akhnafovich FAMIYEV

1960

Yekaterinburg

Yuliya Yevgenyevna FEDOTOVA

56087/22

Alekhin v.

Russia

18/11/2022

Yevgeniy Vyacheslavovich ALEKHIN

1976

Moscow

Ilnur Ilgizovich SHARAPOV

56627/22

Brosse v.

Russia

27/11/2022

Stepan Viktorovich BROSSE

1993

Cheboksary

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

57019/22

Kuznetsova v.

Russia

13/11/2022

Tatyana Leonidovna KUZNETSOVA

1970

Lahdenpohja

Mariya Sergeyevna ZYRYANOVA

57024/22

Vostrov v.

Russia

20/11/2022

Vadim Yevgenyevich VOSTROV

1972

Krasnoyarsk

Vladimir Valeryevich VASIN

57567/22

Mezin and Others v.

Russia

18/11/2022

Mikhail Yefimovich MEZIN

1965

St Petersburg

Denis Alekseyevich GORBACHEV

1988

Voronezh

Dmitriy Alwksandrovich SMELYY

1976

Shopino

Yelizaveta Romanovna TSENKER

1997

Elektrostal

Andrey Petrovich ZAKHOBA

1981

Moscow

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

57577/22

Giricheva v.

Russia

19/11/2022

Marina Antonovna GIRICHEVA

1999

Nizhniy Novgorod

Konstantin Mikhaylovich ZINOVYEV

57580/22

Titov v.

Russia

02/12/2022

Aleksandr Vyacheslavovich TITOV

1977

Yekaterinburg

Sergey Yuryevich TIUNOV

57642/22

Chernyakevich v.

Russia

05/12/2022

Marina Nikolayevna CHERNYAKEVICH

1991

Moscow

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

57672/22

Glushkov v.

Russia

02/12/2022

Aleksey Alekseyevich GLUSHKOV

1964

Petrozavodsk

Nataliya Nikolayevna CHERNOVA

57857/22

Kuznetsov v.

Russia

28/11/2022

Aleksey Fedorovich KUZNETSOV

1961

Tula

Aleksey Valeryevich VLASOV

121/23

Kislyakova and Others v.

Russia

11/11/2022

Anna Alekseyevna KISLYAKOVA

2003

Yekaterinburg

Artem Mikhaylovich MEDVEDEV

1989

Khimki

Dmitriy Vladimirovich ZHMYREV

1989

Inzhavino

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

280/23

Kulikovskaya v.

Russia

28/11/2022

Darya Aleksandrovna KULIKOVSKAYA

1991

Azov

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

320/23

Kozhinskaya v.

Russia

14/11/2022

Mariya Aleksandrovna KOZHINSKAYA

1980

Moscow

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

451/23

Kozicheva v.

Russia

26/11/2022

Aleksandra Vladimirovna KOZICHEVA

1996

St Petersburg

Mariya Sergeyevna ZYRYANOVA

464/23

Olkhova v.

Russia

18/11/2022

Olga Aleksandrovna OLKHOVA

1984

Mayskiy

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

476/23

Grigoryev v.

Russia

18/11/2022

Aleksey Vyacheslavovich GRIGORYEV

1977

Petrozavodsk

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

860/23

Moyseyenko v.

Russia

20/11/2022

Georgiy Mefodyevich MOYSEYENKO

1936

Syktyvkar

Vladislav Vladimirovich KOSNYREV

1189/23

Shchekin v.

Russia

08/12/2022

Artem Valentinovich SHCHEKIN

1974

Novosibirsk

1200/23

Olkhovik v.

Russia

02/12/2022

Oleg Aleksandrovich OLKHOVIK

1992

Uspenskoye

Feliks Yevgenyevich VERTEGEL

1385/23

Bezaziyeva v.

Russia

09/12/2022

Susana Rasymivna BEZAZIYEVA

1979

Dzhankoy

Jessica GAVRON

1403/23

Pavlov v.

Russia

21/12/2022

Roman Sergeyevich PAVLOV

1976

Glazov

1517/23

Pishchalnikov v.

Russia

16/12/2022

Aleksandr Sergeyevich PISHCHALNIKOV

1968

Moscow

Valeriya Aleksandrovna ARSHINOVA

1569/23

Malegin v.

Russia

15/12/2022

Vladimir Dmitriyevich MALEGIN

1945

Petrozavodsk

Anatoliy Vadimovich ALEKSANDROVSKIY

1572/23

Vedyagina v.

Russia

15/12/2022

Zhanna Valentinovna VEDYAGINA

1964

Petrozavodsk

1699/23

Chubinidze v.

Russia

10/12/2022

Ketino Borisovna CHUBINIDZE

1993

Moscow

1750/23

Samusev v.

Russia

10/12/2022

Sergey Aleksandrovich SAMUSEV

1978

St Petersburg

Leonid Leonidovich KRIKUN

2006/23

Samorodskaya v.

Russia

09/12/2022

Mariya Aleksandrovna SAMORODSKAYA

1976

Sosnovoborsk

Yekaterina Viktorovna ABASHINA

2023/23

Gutsev v.

Russia

08/12/2022

Aleksandr Viktorovich GUTSEV

1975

Chelyabinsk

Andrey Gennadyevich LEPEKHIN

2084/23

Ivanov v.

Russia

05/01/2023

Aleksandr Yuryevich IVANOV

1976

Kaluga

Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN

2088/23

Klyuchko v.

Russia

27/12/2022

Yelena Nikolayevna KLYUCHKO

1980

Kebanyel

Kirill Yevgenyevich ERLIKHMAN

2144/23

Kulesh v.

Russia

14/12/2022

Ivan Pavlovich KULESH

1994

Delft, the Netherlands

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

2867/23

Lyubimov and Others v.

Russia

02/12/2022

Ivan Leonidovich LYUBIMOV

1985

Yekaterinburg

Anastasiya Aleksandrovna FEYGINA

2002

Ryazan

Artem Eduardovich KALLAS

1991

Tambov

Boris Mikhaylovich SHEPELYUK

2002

Moscow

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

3112/23

Matalytskiy v.

Russia

26/12/2022

Artem Yuryevich MATALYTSKIY

1985

Belorechensk

3116/23

OOO Tekhnotorg v.

Russia

31/12/2022

OOO TEKHNOTORG

2009

Yekaterinburg

3733/23

Litvinenko v.

Russia

16/12/2022

Pavel Ilyich LITVINENKO

1997

Balashikha

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

3836/23

Salmina v.

Russia

24/12/2022

Kseniya Maksudovna SALMINA

1997

Tolyatti

4802/23

Levina v.

Russia

06/01/2023

Svetlana Igorevna LEVINA

1991

Ryazan

Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN

4828/23

Krasilnikov and Others v.

Russia

28/12/2022

Mark Nikolayevich KRASILNIKOV

1992

Yekaterinburg

Olga Mikhaylovna SVALOVA

1956

Moscow

Ilya Yevgenyevich YERMIN

1982

Volzhskiy

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

4920/23

Akhunov v.

Russia

13/01/2023

Dzhamil Ildarovich AKHUNOV

1994

Kazan

Rim Faridovich SABIROV

5107/23

Ispodina v.

Russia

14/01/2023

Galina Petrovna ISPODINA

1961

Medvezhyegorsk

Nataliya Nikolayevna CHERNOVA

5369/23

Tanakov v.

Russia

13/01/2023

Pavel Yevgenyevich TANAKOV

1991

Kemerovo

Sarkis Simonovich DARBINYAN

6879/23

Yevtushenko v.

Russia

20/01/2023

Anna Timofeyevna YEVTUSHENKO

1994

New York City, NY, USA

Olga Yuryevna NECHAYEVA

7437/23

Motsak v.

Russia

23/12/2022

Aleksey Viktorovich MOTSAK

1982

Tashkent

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

7446/23

Livadnaya and Vasilyev v.

Russia

06/01/2023

Irina Valeryevna LIVADNAYA

1980

Moscow

Konstantin Olegovich VASILYEV

1987

Khimki

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

7824/23

Balyasin v.

Russia

14/01/2023

Roman Alekseyevich BALYASIN

1981

Zheleznogorsk

Vladimir Valeryevich VASIN

8102/23

Arinichev v.

Russia

16/12/2022

Vladislav Vitalyevich ARINICHEV

1993

Druzhba

8961/23

Dubyaga v.

Russia

03/02/2023

Aleksandr Sergeyevich DUBYAGA

1984

Chelyabinsk

Andrey Gennadyevich LEPEKHIN

9050/23

Yermilov v.

Russia

20/01/2023

Aleksey Vladimirovich YERMILOV

1974

St Petersburg

Natalya Andreyevna BARANOVA

10176/23

Kovin v.

Russia

11/02/2023

Vitaliy Sergeyevich KOVIN

1970

Perm

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

10361/23

Kalegin v.

Russia

10/02/2023

Yegor Vladimirovich KALEGIN

2001

Asbest

Kristina Olegovna TYURINA

11179/23

Arbuzenko v.

Russia

27/02/2023

Oksana Ivanovna

ARBUZENKO

1980

Tolyatti

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

11255/23

Prudovskaya v.

Russia

08/02/2023

Lidiya Dmitriyevna PRUDOVSKAYA

1976

Mirnyy

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

11258/23

Petkiyev v.

Russia

08/02/2023

Sergey Sergeyevich PETKIYEV

1993

Elista

Andrey Vasilyevich SABININ

12225/23

Morev v.

Russia

28/02/2023

Andrey Zinovyevich MOREV

1974

Moscow

Ilnur Ilgizovich SHARAPOV

13223/23

Krasnoperov v.

Russia

21/03/2023

Dmitriy Vladimirovich KRASNOPEROV

1985

Moscow

13844/23

Krivtsova and Vorobyeva v.

Russia

07/03/2023

Nikolay Aleksandrovich KRIVTSOV

1991

Moscow

Anna Viktorovna VOROBYEVA

1986

Moscow

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

14506/23

Lyubimov and Latushkin v.

Russia

24/02/2023

Ivan Leonidovich LYUBIMOV

1985

Yekaterinburg

Artem Igorevich LATUSHKIN

1985

Moscow

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

14801/23

Saltevskiy v.

Russia

16/03/2023

Vladimir Aleksandrovich SALTEVSKIY

1986

Novosibirsk

Nataliya Andreyevna BARANOVA

16275/23

Vinogradova v.

Russia

30/03/2023

Katerina Aleksandrovna VINOGRADOVA

1989

Novosibirsk

Olga Yuryevna NECHAYEVA

16701/23

Kuksina v.

Russia

05/04/2023

Nataliya Sergeyevna KUKSINA

1978

Moscow

Anna Yevgenyevna BOCHILO

16711/23

Chebotar v.

Russia

30/03/2023

Ivan Kirillovich CHEBOTAR

1986

St Petersburg

Nikifor Yuryevich IVANOV

16717/23

Baltrukov v.

Russia

30/03/2023

Dmitriy Nikolayevich BALTRUKOV

1979

St Petersburg

Nikifor Yuryevich IVANOV

16721/23

Kiseleva v.

Russia

30/03/2023

Anna Sergeyevna KISELEVA

1985

St Petersburg

Nikifor Yuryevich IVANOV

17386/23

Goldina v.

Russia

06/04/2023

Katalisa Sergeyevna GOLDINA

1972

Novosibirsk

Olga Yuryevna NECHAYEVA

30201/23

Pshenichnikova v.

Russia

19/06/2023

Emiliya Minibayevna PSHENICHNIKOVA

1986

Ufa

Irina Vadimovna SERGEYEVA

Group 2

9512/22

Prokudin v.

Russia

12/02/2022

Aleksandr Sergeyevich PROKUDIN

1990

Tver

Mansur Idrisovich GILMANOV

43083/22

Kara-Murza v.

Russia

24/08/2022

Vladimir Vladimirovich KARA-MURZA

1981

Moscow

Vadim Yuryevich PROKHOROV

45470/22

Gordon v.

Russia

15/09/2022

Dmytro GORDON

1967

Kyiv, Ukraine

Timothy OTTY

45953/22

Skochilenko v.

Russia

28/07/2022

Aleksandra Yuryevna SKOCHILENKO

1990

St Petersburg

Varvara Dmitriyevna MIKHAYLOVA

48520/22

Afanasyev v.

Russia

07/10/2022

Mikhail Vyacheslavovich AFANASYEV

1976

Abakan

Tumas Arsenovich MISAKYAN

57229/22

Naki v.

Russia

02/12/2022

Maykl Sidney NAKI

1993

Moscow

Stanislav Aleksandrovich SELEZNEV

Group 3

49918/19

Vanslova and Others v.

Russia

18/09/2019

Yekaterina Mikhaylovna VANSLOVA

1990

Nizhniy Novgorod

Ivan Vladimirovich ZHILTSOV

1982

Nizhniy Novgorod

Anton Vladimirovich PRUSAKOV

1983

Nizhniy Novgorod

Mikhail Mikhaylovich SOLUNIN

1988

Nizhniy Novgorod

Bashir Izrailovich PLIYEV

1968

Pliyevo

Olga Aleksandrovna SADOVSKAYA

51424/19

Yelagina and Others v.

Russia

18/09/2019

Aleksandrina Vyacheslavovna YELAGINA

1991

Moscow

Nikita Andreyevich PROTSENKO

1987

Moscow

Oystein WINDSTAD

1983

Oslo, Norway

Kirill Nikolayevich KOROTEEV

Group 4

29440/19

Dupuy v.

Russia

17/05/2019

Elsa Marie DUPUY

1952

Lausanne, Switzerland

Ivan Yuryevich PAVLOV

12396/21

Kulakova and Others v.

Russia

28/01/2021

Yevgeniya Yuryevna KULAKOVA

1988

St Petersburg

Olga Nikolayevna STARTSEVA

1990

St Petersburg

Yelena Igorevna KONDRAKHINA

1987

Kolpino

Olga Nikolayevna STARTSEVA

61350/21

Prudovskiy v.

Russia

08/12/2021

Sergey Borisovich PRUDOVSKIY

1949

Moscow

MEMORIAL HUMAN RIGHTS CENTRE

25390/22

International Memorial v.

Russia

28/04/2022

INTERNATIONAL MEMORIAL

1991

Moscow

MEMORIAL FRANCE

Group 5

57131/21

Twitter, Inc. v.

Russia

18/11/2021

TWITTER, INC.

2007

San Francisco, CA, USA

Jonathan PRICE

9177/22

Meta Platforms, Inc. v.

Russia

28/01/2022

META PLATFORMS, INC.

Menlo Park, CA, USA

Maya LESTER

37027/22

OOO Google and Others v.

Russia

27/07/2022

OOO GOOGLE

2005

Moscow, Russia

GOOGLE IRELAND LTD

2003

Dublin, Ireland

GOOGLE INTERNATIONAL LLC

2002

Wilmington, DE, USA

GOOGLE LLC

2002

Wilmington, DE, USA

Timothy OTTY